Papa Fattoush Restaurant

15 E Main St #100, Carmel - 46032
231 reviews
Mediterranean Greek
(317) 564-8782

First time there after the fire at Adel's Gyros where we have been going for years and honestly has some of the best gyros I've ever had. Sadly, the gyros at Papa Fattoush was incredibly bland and utterly forgettable. However, everything else we tried was very, very good. My wife had the lamb platter with a very generous portion and tender, tasty chunks of skewered lamb. The grape leaves were on the small side, but very tasty with a light dusting of sumac. The spanakopita was dense, not flaky but had amazing depth of flavor. The baklava was a tad too moist, but an otherwise excellent way to end the meal. I look forward to returning to try the falafel and shawarma but will have to stave off my gyros cravings until Adel's reopens.

This was our 1st time here and it was phenomenal Christ was good serving portions were large absolutely wonderful.My wife had a Greek salad with gyro meat, and I had the falafel with salad we had grape leaves for appetizer and everything like I said was wonderful.We dug in and ate it was so good we didn't stop so we didn't get any pictures but presentation was great and we'll definitely be back.

I am absolutely inlove with this place. I order from them every week! I gave 4 stars because of the lack of consistency. Ive been ordering the Gyro Greek salad once or twice a week for the past several months and I never know what dressing is going to come with or what toppings will be on it. It is so bizarre. Several times it was perfect, but the last few times there were a few chickpeas and a carrot thrown on top with balsamic dressing...what is Greek about that?that?! I've even written notes with my order, "please include all toppings". I look forward to eating out and I would like to know what I am paying for and what I am getting. I've stopped ordering because I've just been so disappointed lately.

I have typically had pretty good experience and the food is usually very good but recently the restaurant hasn’t been very clean & I know many places are having a hard time with staffing. I really wish them the best and hope they can continue to share their good food in a well staffed and clean environment.

Amazing Halal food... workers are quite biased towards the chicken and gyro so I stayed within their recommendations. Glad I did, Gyro with salad and got a gyro with fries Togo since it was so savory. Definitely will be back whenever I'm in the area. #Bismillah

Very good food. Their falafel are made to perfection. Their hummus, fries, and bread(naan) is also great. The gyros are very neat heavy, but still taste great. Had to split one with my brother.

such good food and good price and the owners are nice people

Very fresh, delicious and big portion of Gyro combo. Love ordering food here. Highly recommend!

Papa Fattoush is my go to meditarranean halal takeout and dine in for 1.5 years now. Nestled in the heart of Carmel, their spicy gyro salad (grilled meat ) is deh-lish-ush!!! They offer takeout through door dash and have a variety of vegetarian options such as falafel, hummus, baba ganoush and spanakopita. All with your choice of spices. Reasonably priced, with huge portions. Friendly owner and great space to sit outside too in good weather days!

The shawarma was very dry and the kufta was dry and overdone to a char. It was also overpriced, especially for the low quality and lack of flavor. Not very authentic as well, my partner is Arab and was less than impressed.