Mellow Mushroom Carmel

2340 E 116th St, Carmel - 46032
191 reviews
Pizza
(317) 846-2400

We are huge mellow mushroom fans and pretty much come here every weekend. Service is great and their food never fails to make us happy. Their dough is better than anything in town. Recommend their cloud 9 wings and the Thai dye pizza.The folks that work there are very nice and accommodating. I accidentally ordered the wrong pizza for takeout and only realized it when I got there to pick it up. I was so disappointed and thought we were going to be stuck with a pizza that we like, but did not want that evening (I ordered pacific rim instead of the Thai dye). They were so understanding and made a small version of the correct pizza in 7 minutes and let us keep the first one too. Really grateful for what they did. It really made our evening!!

First time at Mellow Mushroom and they have vegan cheese!!! I love dairy but dairy doesn't love me. Really good service/vibe and food.

Surprised by how expensive it is - either prices went up or this location is more pricey than other MM's I've been to. But pretzels are too die for, I always go out of my way to get some whenever I'm in Indy.

Great, affordable lunch specials! Fresh ingredients and amazing service! Something for everyone!

This place was great. Food, service. I especially love their salads. Always fresh.

Excellent food and service- highly recommend

Service is always great and the pizza is excellent. I recommend the Holy Shiitake and Mighty Meaty. They also have Gluten Free and vegan options. Beer and Wine only but good local beer selection

One of the best pizzas I've ever had! From meat lovers to vegan they have all the pizza bases covered. As the name implies it's a very laid back place. The wall art is cool and the Greatful Dead playing in the background was an awesome touch. I will be back. This is a must see place, especially if your a hippy!

Asked for a NON BURNT PIZZA and twice they brought out one that was charcoaled on the bottom. It looked like the crust was made out of charcoal and dirt. Got food poisoning from their mushroom soup several months ago, but wanted to try them one more time. This visit was even worse. HORRIBLE PIZZA!!!!!!

Awesome experience and even better food! Had the cheesy bread and The merry prankster! Both were reasonably priced. Cheesy bread, pizza, and 1 drink with tip less than 40. Highly recommend.