Greek Tony's Pizza & Sub Shop

1732 E 116th St, Carmel - 46032
180 reviews
Pizza
(317) 846-1200

Best breadsticks ever……. Great atmosphere and the staff is outstanding

Waited 30 min for food and there were only 1 person ahead of me. I had a order of breadstix and one slice of pizza. Breadstix were good, pizza was bland and burnt. Plus the dining room wasnt well kept. Old bar tables and chairs, dirty and saw a roach on the floor. Wont be back.

One of, if not my favourite pizza place in Carmel. If you ask for extra cheese, they put a comically large amount of cheese on it. Great breadsticks too.

I've never eaten here, but my husband did many years ago. It did not disappoint! Huge portions. Awesome breadsticks. Pizza was great. Hubs said the staff was super nice. This will definitely be a new pizza go to place for us.

Awesome place to eat. The people are friendly and it’s a very clean restaurant

Went here for the first time on my lunch break. Holy cow the pizza slice was huge and delicious(: their breadsticks are huge too and super fluffy.

I got the Gyro Platter. It really wasn't very good. The meat was charred a bit and dry. The salad was a bit tiny. I have had the pizza here and it was much better, but the gyro plate wasn't enjoyable. I will stick to the pizza. I just didn't feel like the meat was fresh or it wasn't handled well.

2018 review: Might be my favorite pizza around. The breadsticks are pretty amazing too. I eat lunch here at least once a month.2022 update: Stopped in for lunch for the first time in quite a while - still GREAT! Pizza is perfect, nice beer selection, and they have some new items on the menu. This is an awesome neighborhood spot. Only thing is I don't like the switch to a slightly mixed greens type salad rather than just iceberg. Still ate it up!

Quick good food. Service was friendly, polite and fast. The breadsticks are to die for, make sure to order some.

They always do a great job with my large pick up order. The food is always correct, hot, and delicious.