Broken Barrel — Carmel

1156 Keystone Way S, Carmel - 46032
67 reviews
Whiskey Bar Cocktail Bar Lounges
(317) 663-8168

We love the vibe of this place! Always friendly staff ready and willing to recommend whiskeys, answer questions, and give great service. Excellent and unique cocktails, and good food from Wolfies next door.

Spoke to the manager Amy about an employee that was sick. There was nothing wrong with the service that we got from the bartender Paige. She was amazing. Amy the manager stated she personally takes temperatures of every employee several times throughout their shift. We go in all the time and have never seem Amy taking temperatures. She also stated the every employee washes their hands after everything they touch. Which is impossible in the restaurant business. She proceeded to tell me that she can't talk about her employees being sick because it violates HIPPA. But also said she took the bartenders temperature 3 times and she just has allergies. We will not be back. They need better management.

It was excellent! Hidden gem for sure

Such a neat little bar off on its own in Carmel! Feels like a speakeasy when walking in, and the atmosphere is nice and cozy. Love the Blood & Sand drink! Can't wait to come back for more!

Best bourbon. Best food. Best service. We make this a top priority stop every time we are in town!

This is a cute little lounge with amazing drinks and a great bartender!

Great bar with a good, wide selection of Bourbon. Great ambiance.

Such a intimate atmosphere. I love how comfy it is in the Broken Barrel. I’m not that big into Bourbon, but I still really appreciate the huge selection of it that they have. I love that they carry food too!

Such a intimate atmosphere. I love how comfy it is in the Broken Barrel. I’m not that big into Bourbon, but I still really appreciate the huge selection of it that they have. I love that they carry food too!

Went here for my birthday dinner during the week. My fiance and I were the only ones in this section of the restaurant. Our food was reasonably priced and delicious. We had a fantastic conversation with the bartender about bourbons. She was very knowledgeable.