I had the horse shoe. EVERYONE in Springfield knows it's all about the cheese sauce! They at least have it!!However, when I order a buffalo breaded chicken breast horse shoe, and get a single piece of regular bread (not toasted) with a couple of chicken strips dredged in the horse shoe with the buffalo sauce on the side, then THAT is a problem!
Delicious food, nice atmosphere, efficient/friendly staff! A must try, you will not be disappointed!
Amazing food, great service and awesome prices. Costelloe's Pizza is the best. Hands down.
New location, same great tasting food. Excellent staff and service. The Pizza is in my opinion in the Top 3 Best pizza in the Springfield IL area. Give them a try you'll be happy you did.
This place never disappoints. Delicious wings, pizza, Chili, Italian beef and what surprised me the most was the cheeseburger. It has to be one of if not the best around here.
Amazing staff. Amazing food. Amazing atmosphere. I couldn't ask for more. Just try it out for yourself. You won't be upset
Great atmosphere, amazing food and the service is top notch. I highly recommend this establishment. You won't be disappointed.
Night out. Service was excellent, staff very accommodating. The food was delicious and the pizza prepared with all fresh ingredients. It was so good. Everything served to us was delicious!
My friend and I ate lunch there yesterday. We both came down with food poisoning. Been there several times before so don’t know what happened. I was sick enough that I won’t go back.
First experience last year was horrendous, but this year was an absolute treat. Great service, amazing food, would totally recommend to friends