First time finally having Pizza Payaa and also trying it as the new dine-in option… nice to have something creative and different… it was so good, we didn’t even pause to take a photo! Couldn’t decide between the Honey Badger and the Sweet Heat (I want a Honey Badger with banana peppers!) but went with the Honey Badger and was not disappointed. I drizzle my pizza with hot honey at home. Definitely a fan. They are not skimpy with the toppings.
LOOK NO FURTHER!!!! If you’re craving GOOD pizza or speciality pizza you need to stop at Pizza Payaa. A hidden gem. So delicious and Adam and Lauren are the best. I recommend the burrata pepperoni pizza or the GLUTEN FREE supreme pizza. Delicious and will be back for more :)
The place is great! A newcomer in town relative to some other pizza establishments but everything about it is fantastic. From the fresh and consistently amazing homemade crust to the always interesting collaborations and unique topping ingredient combinations, they are doing great things. Great pizza vibes and times will keep you interested and coming back for more.
We in town, visiting from Florida (brrrrrr) and this restaurant was highly recommended by our son who lives in Normal. Although the store was a bit difficult to find, the pizza was outstanding!!!Crispy edge, thick crust was perfect. We ordered the mushroom, 3 cheese and shrimp. All were delicious pies but the shrimp was our favorite. One large shrimp positioned on each of the 6 slices & perfectly spiced up with chili-infused hot sauce. Phenomenal & we HIGHLY recommend.When we’re back in the area again, we will definitely be visiting Pizza Payaa.
Absolutely wonderful! Definitely something different. If you like sweet sauce and a thicker crust, this is the pizza for you. A little pricey but I found it worth it with such fresh ingredients and toppings. Looking forward to trying more!
This is hands far the best pizza I've had in my life. I lived in chicago, all the way to California. And this is hands down the best, crust is amazing...sauce is so delicious..Adam likes to use local produce and meat...everything is fresh and delicious!! Always my go to place for pizza.
By far the best pizza I have ever had! The owner provided food for our education conference, so sweet! The hot honey on the pizza is an amazing flavor. The caramelized cheese edge is to die for and the pizza's with Mikes Hot Honey Drizzle are 10/10. I will be ordering for all of my friends and family! New favorite restaurant.
BEST PIZZA EVER! Literally ever, I could eat it every day. The different variations make every one it's own special pie! It's amazing how much culinary work can go into a PIZZZA! I can NOT WAIT to try the lobster pie and plan to drive two hours away on New Year's Eve!
Good pizza, although pricey. Excellent dough — you can really feel the difference. I thought the pizzas were a tad light on the sauce and would've liked more. Followed their reheating instructions but it didn't quite taste the same the following day. Mike's hot honey was a real winner. Excellent customer service. Anthony was super friendly and nice.
Absolutely Amazing!! I cannot say enough good things about their pizza! My favorite is the honey badger and their speciality pizzas are fabulous! I’ve liked them all. The crust is to die for. I drive 50 miles round trip to pick one up! It is that good!