Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs

840 E Alameda Rd, Pocatello - 83201
131 reviews
Pizza Salad
(208) 232-6931

Our favorite place to eat. Best sandwiches in town and my kids love their pizza and pizza subs. Great service.

First off, it was the best place but if the workers hang up on customers, how do you expect to stay in business. If a customer calls and asks where there order is after almost two hours, you don't get rude with them and then hang up. Then when they try to cal back and ignore their call until they call from another phone, just to hang up on them again, someone needs to lose their job. Order was returned and my money better be returned. I'll be in to talk to a person in charge soon!

It was awesome! We had a taco pizza the ingredients were fresh and not greasey! The salad was fantastic also, all fresh and large portion. We had corn dogs for the littles and those were fantastic as well. We called early, they answered the phone and arrived in a timely manner. The service was friendly and respectful. I recommend this place and supporting their business.

We love Papa Kelseys the sandwiches, the pizza and the garlic bread are so good. We have never had anything bad it always is good. Our favorite is the Taco Pizza & the steak sandwich.

food is tolerable not good but the service is on a whole nother level never have I been to an establishment like this before the owner was nothing but rude and was screaming at one of the empolyyees when I walked in he was a bigger guy who treated me like i was wasting his time becuase i was unfamiliar with the menu which doesnt even have wingsby the way id consider going back if it wasnt for the bad service

Very poor quality and ingredients. The pastrami sandwich had 1 thin slice of meat. Crust is bad. Cheese on pizza was plasticy. You've been warned.

Used to really like their subs and didn’t mind spending 25 bucks for two sandwiches until tonight. Must be trying to step over dollars to pick up dimes because both of our sandwiches were junk. Changed the bread, low quality/smaller meat portions, the sauce was different/gross definitely not worth 25 dollars… should have just went to subway. Also called to ask what was different and all the kid said was we’ll tell the owners you’re not the first to complain. ? fix the problem, pretty unfortunate to lose regular customers over trying to save a penny.

Friendly swrvice. Had soup & sandwich. Good food but crackers were stale. Mentioned it to them, they gave me a new bowl, thanked me & threw out the rest if the crackers. I'm empressed they listened & rectified the problem.

Had salad wa as made the way I asked. Friendly staff Sandwiches are good. love the bread

Great family friendly place with tasty food!