Fifth Street Bagelry

559 S 5th Ave, Pocatello - 83201
201 reviews
Bagels Coffee & Tea
(208) 235-1311

As always the staff was so kind, they really make you feel like your home.

Followed the sign off the highway, absolutely zero regrets. Friendly and knowledgeable staff, delicious bagel sandwiches, and tasty options for coffee. I got the Stairway to Heaven (fancy mocha with local, extra creamy chocolate milk) iced and a BLT on the Three Cheese bagel. Well worth the detour and I would highly recommend!!

Great bagels, beautiful cookies, amazing varieties, very friendly staff! A must-visit place if you're Pocatello! Look at the map, so many visits from around the world ? even the bathroom was cute!

I have been eating here for years. I love this place for lunch and breakfast but this afternoon I got a lemon blueberry bagel that has fresh blueberries on it. Yum right? Well it was until there was mold on 3 blueberries. Completely unacceptable.

We love coming here every time we come to town! It's our go-to place. The adobo club is my favorite.

Delicious! Good average service from staff. Long lines and waits on the weekends and during lunch rush. But it moves fairly quickly. I've tried their Lox and Cream Cheese and Spicy Italian, but the California Club is a classic, my favorite!

I love 5th Street's bagels! The three cheese with garlic and herb cream cheese is my favorite combo--so yummy! The atmosphere is super relaxed and fun, and even when it's busy (which it often is because it's so good), the service is quick. Highly recommend!

Really good customer service and bagels! However, I can never tell when their drive through is open. While some bagels might be more expensive, they're good quality and delicious. Their coffee drinks are good too. They're usually very busy, but their service is still quick. If you order a drink expect to a wait few extra minutes. They also have the best orange juice!Pictured: The pilgrim with lettuce, tomato, and cucumber

The bagels are good but the coffee has been consistently mediocre. On our last visit (morning of 3/16) we waited 20 minutes for a blended chai - long enough that the rest of our to-go order had gone cold - and it ended up being mostly foam. The parking situation needs help too - the only way out of one side of the parking lot is through the drive through OR out of a one-way entrance-only drive onto a one-way street. The bagels are good enough to have me come back, but I think we're probably done getting drinks here.

They were busy so there was a short wait but so worth it. I got a lox and cream cheese on spinach and parm and 10/10. The bagles are perfect and fresh, the staff was nice and it tastes exactly like it's supposed to.