Tried Mountain Mike's for the first time the other day, in this case the lunch buffet. Not being from Kali, we weren't familiar with the chain and have never been to one anywhere else.Pizza was good, but the pizza bar (which had room for 4 pizzas) never had more than the equivalent of about one pizza plus a couple of slices on it in total- they need to keep up with this a lot better if they want to keep the lunchtime crowd.The pizza itself was pretty good- on par with Idaho Pizza Co or even slightly better, I would say.The floor of the place was visibly dirty, with visible food debris. There were enough people working for someone to at least make a pass with a broom, but you could see it really needed to be mopped. This sort of thing makes an impact on customer perception.Overall, not a bad experience. Employees were friendly, and the food was good. One of these days we want to try a whole pizza made to order.
I saw some reviews about Mountain Mike's Pizza. Several reviews said the pizza was fabulous. Several reviews didn't.So, I thought we would try it and see for ourselves. The ordering process was difficult. I downloaded the app and it awful. I called the location and asked if there were specials. The gal (super nice) said they have 15% off. I asked how to do it on the app, as there was nothing there. She told me she would show me when I came in to pick up the pizza.I ordered 3 large pizzas and a large garlic cheese sticks. When I showed the gal my app she said she didn't know why the deal wasn't on there, but she could add it on her side. However, because I didn't order online I couldn't get the reward points.The pizza looked delicious. The taste just wasn't there. The crust was thick, there was hardly any sauce, and just no flavor. Usually, my crew devours 3 large pizzas. We had 2 full pizzas and almost all the cheese sticks left because no one liked it.For $80 worth of food it should be good! I guess we are spoiled with Idaho Pizza. It's just hard to find good pizza after having Idaho Pizza.The staff was great. I will give them that!Our first and last time here unfortunately.
Dirty inside. Really no place clean to sit. 4 people working and just standing around and flirting with each other. Very disappointed in the cleanliness and taste of the pizza. Way too much sauce and not much cheese. Not the way I remember Mt Mikes. Guess I’ll have to stick to Idaho Pizza.
We tried Mountain Mikes tonight for the first time. We ordered pickup. It was ready in no time. The pizzas were perfect. The whole family enjoyed them. Even my picky six year old. We also ordered wings. The stingin’ honey garlic and plain. They were tasty as well. We always bring ours home and pop them in the air fryer to crisp them up. And they were still juicy after that.Thanks for a great dinner Mountain Mikes! We’ll be back!! (-:
I ordered the pineapple chicken luau pizza with extra sauce, green onions and a side order of garlic bread with cheese.The pizza was decent but it didn't look like there was much for sauce on it... definitely considered it light on sauce. The garlic bread was extremely sad looking, for $5 you'd definitely expect more from it.I might give them another chance but nothing special as far as pizza goes, especially for $30. I wouldn't even consider Mountain Mike's in my top 5 for pizza places.
Grew up near a Mountain Mikes pizza in Santa Clara CA. When I heard that there was one going in to Meridian, I geeked out. Have been several times since they have opened and the taste brings back the nostalgia of my childhood. Have always loved the crispy pepperoni. Its my new/old go to for pizza
Hands down my favorite pizza in Idaho, their sauce is fantastic,the staff is friendly and polite, they have happy employees, and the freshest ingredients.They have a pizza called the mountain it's ridiculously huge,this is the first and only Mountain Mike's location in Idaho,if you love pizza they got some of the best.Go see em.
I’ve been gone twice. It was soooo yummy.My children love Mountain Mike’s Pizza.Children’s favorite is pineapple chicken pizza.My favorite is pepperoni.
Came in on Sat afternoon plenty of room to dine in, got the large half Hawaiian half Everest. Just like I remember from Kali. 5 stars to the staff, couple young men with positive, professional and gracious behavior. Easy to engage and pleasant to interact with. Pizza very very good IMHO.
The problem with most California franchises that open up in Idaho, is they stray too far from the original.Not the case here. Mountain Mikes tastes like I remember growing up in California. The crispy pepperoni is the signature that makes this really good pizza.