I had their Cauliflower crust pizza with pepperoni - it was decent (sure do miss reg pizza though). Wife had two slices of a reg pepperoni pizza - they're huge slices, could have just did one. Caesar salad was shared between us and okay. Busy little place. With two pops and tip $40. Hit the spot, had leftovers, and there were other places we enjoyed more, so didn't go back a second time.
Best pizza ever. The crust is simply superb and the cheese is somehow amazing! Don’t go anywhere else for pizza. Oh. And the calzone is the best I’ve ever had! The ricotta cheese put it over the top! I could keep going on about this place. But I won’t. Just go there
Visiting Maui for the first time, my family found this amazing pizza spot. The pizza checked off every box, great flavor, crispy and chewy crust, fresh sauce, delicious toppings. I can't stress this enough, this was one of the best pizzas I've ever had.The establishment is pretty small, but they do have comfortable seating for mid size groups. The service was first class and everything came out hot and fresh in a short time. We are early to avoid the rush, which probably helped, but I would happily have waited for this truly phenomenal pizza.Will definitely be coming back whenever we visit Maui again.
Delicious! So much flavor and perfect texture! My wife and I got the Old World Pizza with pepperoni. It went well with a couple of Maui beers and a side Ceasar salad. The staff are great, really chill crew. There's neat outdoor seating (you cannot drink alcoholic beverages outside). It's a good vibe. We paid about $25 a person with a good tip. They make by the slice too.
Cute little hut! Staff is super friendly. Pizza is ABSOLUTELY delicious! As are the salads! Ingredients are very fresh. And, depending on the time of the year of your visit, if you happen to be sitting outside, you get mangos falling from the sky! Well, not literally “the sky”, just a tree near by, but…”mangos falling from the sky” sounds more magical! Lol
The pizza was great and had large portions! Definitely worth the money. The large pizza with tip costed us $40 for 2 people and we had plenty of leftovers to take home. They also give you red pepper flakes and Parmesan for takeout.
had the meat lovers pizza with fresh tomatoes and mushrooms added and a bottle of wine - delicious! service was great! it is more expensive than most but worth it if you enjoy a nice pie!
Delicious pizza. We got two pizzas, all meat and Hawaiin with ham and pineapple. Both were delicious. Don't wait until you're starving to order though. It is so good and busy. However, ours was ready when it was supposed to be.
We have been considering Prison Street Pizza for our last several visits but just couldn't manage to get there at dinner time. This visit we made it a point to get there and I am very pleased that we did. The Margherita pizza was tops. Fresh pesto, fresh tomatoes and a savory taste topped the thin crust. This was a pizza home run in my book. Free parking in the lot directly across the street and only a few doors down from Front Street. A must if your group is looking for a great pizza.
Was here yesterday for a late lunch. Serpico pizza and mozzarella salad hit the spot. Blonde Bikini lager perfect pairing. Friendly folks and good service. Just be aware there is no bathroom. Nearest one is a public one at the waterfront.