Island Cream Co.

305 Keawe St #511, Lahaina - 96761
349 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Gelato Shaved Ice
(808) 298-0916

Stopped by here and expected an average ice cream shop but was pleasantly surprised at how good the ice cream was. They have special sundaes and concoctions. All were very good. Service was great too. Would return.

Went here to get Shave Ice but ended up with Ice Cream. They had so many choices it was hard to decide what to try.

We had a great experience here. We tried a few different flavors before we each made our decisions to buy ice cream. We had great service and great ice cream!

Great flavors and perfect serving amount! Family of five , we each got two scoops and it came out to be around 45$ ! And let me tell you BEST MONEY WE EVER SPENT! Coco-moco and peanut butter pie were our favorites ! We will definitely be back!

We visited on a whim since the shaved ice places were closed. We were all pleasantly surprised with some really good ice cream. They have other offerings as well.

The local ice cream was very good, the Smoosh Shave Ice was also very good. The standard Shave Ice that is manually flavored was meh. The service was also meh - we were rushed out the door at closing, on our second stop in they just weren't very friendly. But I would def go again when in Lahaina.

Love this ice cream place. They have a great variety of the best flavors and great customer service.

This shaved ice and ice creamy Gelatoey stuff is delicious, the place is small so be forwarned, the sploshy 1/2 strawberry and 1/2 mango with a small scoop of ice cream with condensed milk drizzle was a highlight!

This place is amazing for a quick snack. They will let you sample any of the flavors before hand. They were super helpful in recommending items. Lots of places to park. They have smoothies, ice cream, shakes, and some drinks. Highly recommend!

For a specialty ice cream type shop, this place is pretty good. Some unique flavors, have shakes, ice cream, shave ice… a great sweets stop. Folks are friendly too. Across the highway from the water and nothing about the setting so not quite a 5- star, but hits the spot for a sweet craving