Years ago, I remember discovering theMaui Cookie Lady's cookies through Yelpwhile trying to plan a trip to Maui. I wasable to find the huge stuffed cookies atthe Maui Ocean Center's gift shop. Fastforward to now and Mitzi, the MauiCookie Lady, is baking cookies for thestars and has been featured in RachelRay and O Magazine and has her owncookie website for easy online ordering.I look forward to visiting her new store in Makawao, but for now will continue to order her cookies online. The extra large cookies are made with ingredients that she locally sources whenever possible. My family’s favorite is the Half-Baked: a gigantic cookie stuffed with Reese's, Snickers & Oreo. We also enjoy trying her new flavors that are always so creative. Her cookies have been my go-to gift tosend and share some Aloha to friends.Her story of her hard work and her dedication to quality resulting in a successful locally and woman owned business is an absolute inspiration.
Do yourselves a favor & splurge on a few (or more) of these cookies - you'll be happy you did! Every year that we're in Maui we HAVE to stop by to see the Maui Cookie Lady herself, Mitzi, & get some of her delicious cookies — also make sure you stock up, they store perfectly in the freezer. I remember the first time we tried them, they had a little shop set up in the Maui Pack & Ship in Kahului - we were blown away then & we're blown away now, several years later. The new shop in Makawao fits the historic town beautifully. You walk in & you're instantly whisked away to a dreamland filled with sweet treats - the decor, the sights, sounds & smells! Once you bite into the cookies, you'll be asking yourself why you didn't buy more! Our favorite is Da Half Baked & anything with peanut butter, but we love trying her seasonal flavors. The Maui Cookie Lady is a part of our family's annual Maui trip & we look forward to it every single time - Mitzi is a doll, the staff is great, the shop looks awesome & the cookies....oh, the cookies!
If you love soft, chewy, and DECADENT cookies these are for you!! Just look at how huge these are!! They're moist and dense; the perfectttt texture for a cookie in my opinion, and the fillings add a nice crunch. Tons of different flavors too, can't wait to try more!
I first received a batch of these cookies as a gift. Then I was at a wedding at Sugar Beach Events in Maui. They were part of the dessert table! I was so thrilled and excited. These are the best, most delicious and unique cookies I’ve ever tasted in my life. I love Da Half Baked and plan to try them all. I also plan to buy gift cards and send to family and friends for this delicious treat.
I have had several opportunities to eat these unique and delicious cookies. I was attending a wedding and they were part of the dessert table. Then I received a batch as a gift. I plan to buy several gift cards to pass on to family and friends so they can also try this delicious treat
We visited the Maui Cookie Lady’s storefront on our most recent visit to Maui. We loved it! We have been buying cookies from her for years but this was the first time to the store. It was a fantastic experience and the cookies are to die for. We came home with almost 40 cookies so that we could share with some of my small business customers. Can’t wait to go back again.
The Maui Cookie Lady has the BEST cookies around. We just got to visit her storefront this last visit to Maui and it was so amazing. She did a fabulous job creating such a fantastic space. The cookies are still amazing. We can’t wait to go back again for more!! If you can’t visit you can always order online! You won’t be disappointed
The cookies we tried were great! Not a very big shop but everybody waited patiently inline the day we stopped
The oatmeal walnut dark chocolate cookie was amazing ? highly recommended ?
Before receiving this cookie (“Da Half Baked”), I was so excited to try after seeing all of the ingredients. After just one single bite, i was AMAZED by how delicious it was! It completely exceeded my expectations. All of the world’s favorite candies and cookies rolled up into one scrumptious treat! A variety of flavors all into one delectable treat, that will have your taste buds bursting with flavor. There’s no other brand of cookies that can compete with this one - I will definitely be ordering more!