The Mill Pizza Buffet & Games

1337 Baytree Rd, Valdosta - 31602
134 reviews
Buffet Pizza Arcades
(229) 469-4369

Manager made a point of letting me know someone must of taken signs of games that were broken before he finally gave me back the kids tokens. It doesn't matter that you are upset that customers took the broken signs down. Just make it right and dont talk negatively about how customers. Good, bad or ugly the customer pays your check. I just want to enjoy my grandson's birthday!! It also needs to be cleaner.plates and trashcan were falling over. Short handed I understand but after 3 hours of being there and still no one walked around to clean.

We absolutely loved the pizza! The salad bar was also nice with a good variety. I requested a dessert pizza and they made "Georgia On My Mind" which was delicious! The kids had a blast in their game room and the staff was very friendly and helpful! The entire place was decked out with really cool memorabilia! We will definitely be back on our next trip to Valdosta!

Lots of broken games. Kind of disappointing. Inside looked neglected. Broken games and equipment piled up by the doors. Salad bar was dirty. Dressings we’re watery and had old food floating in them. Drink machine flavors were labeled wrong. Only one side of the ice cream machine worked.

Great place! Looks small but actually big on the inside and was very accommodating to the 3 buses we pulled up in with over 120 teens, several directors, and many chaperones. Will stop there again when traveling thru that area!

My kids always have a blast here whether if it's for a birthday party or just a fun day out. The buffet is very good, especially the Buffalo chicken pizza and the salad is very fresh. The only caveat is that several of the arcade games seem to always be down, which is a shame bc they look very fun and even I would waste time playing them. The staff are always friendly and helpful with smiles on their faces though and it's always as clean as it can be. My most recent visit they had a 100 A health and cleanliness rating. All in all, solid 4 stars and will keep returning!

The pizza was great and reasonably priced. The arcade, not so much. A lot of the games were out of order. Some wouldn’t give you your tickets. I had to keep asking for someone to give my niece the tickets the game showed it owed her but it was out of actual tickets. They acted like it was a burden and I ended up standing by the game for 20 minutes waiting before I had to go find someone. They have very few tickets per game and the prize for 50 tickets was a tiny tootsie roll and 300 for a bigger one so you can easily pay $5-$20 quickly for a piece of candy. I’d go back for the pizza but Id rather turn my nieces loose in the Dollar Tree with a $20 bill.

5 star all around. Amazing food, amazing decorations. Everything is amazing. Classic pizza dive with a great retro feel. I'd come back to Georgia just to eat here!

My kids always have a blast here whether if it's for a birthday party or just a fun day out. The buffet is very good, especially the Buffalo chicken pizza and the salad is very fresh. The only caveat is that several of the arcade games seem to always be down, which is a shame bc they look very fun and even I would waste time playing them. The staff are always friendly and helpful with smiles on their faces though and it's always as clean as it can be. My most recent visit they had a 100 A health and cleanliness rating. All in all, solid 4 stars and will keep returning!

The pizza was great and reasonably priced. The arcade, not so much. A lot of the games were out of order. Some wouldn’t give you your tickets. I had to keep asking for someone to give my niece the tickets the game showed it owed her but it was out of actual tickets. They acted like it was a burden and I ended up standing by the game for 20 minutes waiting before I had to go find someone. They have very few tickets per game and the prize for 50 tickets was a tiny tootsie roll and 300 for a bigger one so you can easily pay $5-$20 quickly for a piece of candy. I’d go back for the pizza but Id rather turn my nieces loose in the Dollar Tree with a $20 bill.

Decently priced buffet food that is nice and warm. Great aesthetic, warm and inviting, and friendly staff. Was not over crowded at all when we went. Loved the variety of music playing and it wasn't too loud. Can't wait to go back and play their arcade games !!!