Your Pie Pizza

2201 US Hwy 41, Tifton - 31794
75 reviews
Pizza Italian
(229) 586-8005

This was my first time eating at Your Pie Pizza. We are traveling to Atlanta so the location right off the freeway is perfect!Service was very fast and nice staff! This restaurant is very accommodating to gluten and dairy free eating. The gluten free crust is also dairy free per staff. It was a yummy crust! Definitely recommend.Although the crust was cooked the pizza was lukewarm. Didn’t taste great not being warm. I would come back and just ask for my pizza to stay in a little longer and be served hot.

It was exactly what we needed.. some customization and quick service. That dough piece from Kids pizza kept them so engaged , busy , productive and Happy.. they didn't even ask for tablet.. such a great idea.

it took me almost an hour to order my pizza. the customer service was so mediocre to the point where i did not even want my pizza at the end. when i finally got my pizza it was ok at first but then i realized that most of my ingredients were not even cooked.the meats were delectable but the place was so unkept that there were NOOO DRINKS in the coca-cola freestyle. i can’t believe i experienced this.

Horrible service today. Everytime I order to go for work i have a bad experience. Got there at 12 did not leave until after 12:30 my pizza was sitting there on the rack getting cold. I seen the girl take it down it was the cauliflower crust and on serving tray went up there and stated that I was still waiting for my to go order and then she took it then an boxed it for me. Same thing for my coworker we should not have been over 30 minutes when it was not that busy when we got there. May not ever go back again

Amazing gluten free, dairy free pizza! Fresh ingredients… And gelato!

Probably the worst pizza I have ever had! Crust was burnt on top and bottom! Waitress said I should have told them to make crust thicker!

Loved it best pizza I've had in yrs!!!!

We placed a large order online tonight. We were so delighted to get not Only our food in time. But it also was hot and all correct. It was a difficult order. When we got there the shelf was full of Togo food so they were super busy. Thank you. We have gluten sensitive diets and this is our goto for food. This is the only place in town that we can eat without it making us feel bad. Thank you your pie.

Thank you Your Pie for an outstanding evening and great food. We appreciate that you did this fundraiser for the Animal Shelter. The food was fast, friendly, and delicious. We will be back.

As an ABAC student I’ve been here at least 20 times, they’re always out of something, never get the order correct especially if online, and the guys behind the counter seem too busy flirting with their female coworkers to pay attention to anything else. The management here is horrible or nonexistent. Being from North GA, I’ve loved going to the Your Pie in Clarkesville as it is always perfect with great service. It can’t be found here. Don’t waste your time. Management, if you’re reading this, take a trip to Clarkesville, GA and find out what they’re doing right because you need it.