Amazing place! Love the idea and the pizza definitely did not disappoint! I can't wait to go back!!
Pizza was quite delicious. Went to Skidaway. Gelato nice too. Cute that they have a set up sort of like subway. Thin of course but not bad for a 1 meal setting. I'd visit again.
After eating lots of seafood on our trip to Savannah we decided to get a pizza for our last night. After reading several reviews on Yelp & Google we decided to try Your Pie.It feels a lot like "Blaze" but it was clear that they have higher quality ingredients.We had salads & pizza. The salads were fresh & crunchy. The pizza was not bad - it needed a few more minutes in the oven & to be turned, so that it would be crispy. Because it was undercooked & not turned some of the pieces were slightly doughy.The kids who work here weren't rude - but definitely not well prepared to work with the public. Not personable or friendly.Overall it was kinda "meh" .... Not bad ... not amazing. But just okay.
I called ahead and ordered a few things from Your Pie in Sandfly. I got the Great White Pizza. Extra virgin olive oil, garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, and feta. I added pepperoni and black olives. Also gotten was Zia's Meatball Marinara. Penne, marinara, mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, basil, garlic, and meatball. I asked for mushrooms and extra sauce. Lastly, the House Greek Salad. Romaine, black olives, red onion, banana peppers, feta, Greek dressing. I accidentally put some parm on it, before taking a picture. When I arrived at Your Pie, I called inside to let them know I was there, as I had set up a curbside delivery. I was told there must of been a miscommunication because they didn't do curbside service. On their website, it does have curbside pick up available. The salad was the best tasting of the three items. They are strong flavors together, so that's not a big surprise. I found the pasta on the bland side and did not have the extra sauce on it that was requested. I do not like when my pasta is dry without sauce. The pizza was somewhere in the middle, a little more taste than the pasta. But as you can see, you'll have to even out your own toppings.
If you don't love pizza beer and gelato, then you are missing out on the joys of life. My family loves this place! It's generally pretty difficult to appease 4 and 7 year old boys, but not here! They love eating on the patio outside. The food and service is great. It's a bit pricey but definitely worth it for your own personalized pizza. Very kid friendly (and parent friendly cause... you know...beer). Definitely recommend!
Guys, they have vegan cheese! And I love and appreciate that their whole wheat crust is also vegan--and that's it's thin and brick-oven-style, but not burnt. Nice staff, too.
Very friendly and helpful. The gluten free vegan pizza was good. I also tried their regular dough and it was also good. They had a plant based gelato that had more of an icecream vibe, my kods really enjoyed that.
Ran by kids, no adult manager in site. No one is wearing a hair net of any kind. Very Slow paced. No area for Doordash driver's to pick up food in time. Door dash orders not prepared in a reasonable time.
Really young kids working in this place but luckily we had great service and the food was absolutely amazing. The food was made to order, fresh, designed the way I was carving it. But the kicker was they had the little crunchy ice and that's what really topped it off to be the complete 5 stars.
I usually have great service here. I come often with my daughter because we live nearby. Minus 1 star because Today I experienced unusually bad service. This is the second time this has happened. The People working didn’t seem very friendly to the point where I felt like I was annoying them by being there. I would just advise them to work on consistency with regard to customer experience. Other than that it’s clean and the food is good and fresh.