This is the 2nd time we’ve tried this place. We were not fans of the pizza. Just our own preference. But decided to try it again. We ordered the chicken parmigiana sandwich and a side of pasta salad. The portions were big enough for us to share. That’s about the only good thing I can say. The pasta salad was good. But the chicken on the sandwich was so burnt we couldn’t eat it. Really disappointed because we have friends who love it here and were upset we didn’t like the pizza but talked us into trying again.
My wife said best white pizza with pepperoni and sausage she has ever had. Grandson gave the BBQ pizza an 11 out 5. Granddaughter gave the pepperoni an 8 out 5.
My husband and I ate lunch here today. Plain cheese pizza was perfect NY style. Wouldn't hesitate to visit again. Excellent crust!
My wife and I wanted to change things up from just your typical chain pizza restaurant. And this place was great. I got a pepperoni and meatball pizza and wife a veggie pizza and to say they were great. Even the pretzel knots were great. Two thumbs up
Pizza was good, but gave it 3 stars because it is not a typical pizza buffet: you have to select slices, then they heat them and bring them to you...slow process in middle of lunch hour when the place is full.
Pizza is DELICIOUS, also had Greek and Caesar salad, plus garlic knots, and slices for kids. Kinda dingy and crowded and dated but really I usually get take out. Only once dined in.
This place is a strong and solid... NO. I can't believe the reviews. Something has to be wrong. Soggy pizza. Half of each slice was just mush. JJ please fix that. I will not be returning
Great calzones and spaghetti with meat sauce. Fresh ingredients and outstanding crust. Greek salad, too!
Great NY-style pizza! (...and this is coming from a New Yorker)
Tommy Penirelli is the best pizza maker in this joint.But for real, this place has been a staple of my time in Georgia. From a NYer that enjoys pizza that reminds him of his childhood, I gotta say, there's no better value and quality of NY pizza in Marietta.The lunch special is killer, and for the same price as almost any meal at a Wendy's you can get all you can eat NY-style pizza and suppory a small local business.