The pizza is very consistent and really good. We love ordering pizza from here.As far as the rest of the food, it is very spotty.I’ve ordered chicken parm sub on many occasions and it is never the same.1st time it was egg plant.2nd time was the best.3rd time chopped up pieces of chicken4th time very flat chicken.
Besides the incredible Italian food, the pizza maker with the authentic heavy Italian accent gave me a free slice of pizza when I was doordashing here. He overheard me tell the cashier/hostess how amazing the food on display (pizza by the slice) looked and smelled. He gave me two slices after heating them up for me in their pizza oven and two yummy garlic rolls with sauce!
Amazing Service and Great Food! After walking around the Atlanta history Center all day yesterday, the family decided to try a new pizza place. After all the crazy reviews on Cherokee connect we decided to try I love NY Pizza and pasta. The garlic rolls were amazing, The pizza had a perfect crunch on the crust and the the right cheese and topping ratio. Finished off for a couple of slices of cheesecake. The staff was amazingly attentive, super friendly, and I’m glad we didn’t get takeout but spent time in the restaurant playing 20 questions while waiting on dinner! On a five star scale rating, I would give it a six! We will definitely be back.
Ok growing up in New York City and living in updated New York. I can tell you that this is not the taste of New York style pizza. This is not it. The cheese pizza doesn't not has the sauce taste and the dough is a missed. The cheese you can't mess that up. Also, the garlic knots are not a New York style or flavor. Hit pass and save the disappointment. The wings are not deep fry either. They are bake and you can taste it in the meat. Who eats bake buffalo wings? Definitely not New York People I can tell you that much. You probably get smack in the face if their order was as bad as minds. I would of done it myself but I'm trying to change my ways and live in peace in georgia. Been there done that. Bottom line your better off going to Marco's Pizza or Johnny's Pizza. These two are not great but far better than I love New York Pizza. I pay $42.00 for this order and it won't happen again. Sorry guys you just don't got it. Sad thing is I drove 15 miles on diesel fuel just to be disappointed and out $42.00. Live and learn. Wish you the best with that trash food.
Ok growing up in New York and living in UpState New York. I can tell you that this is not the taste of New York style pizza. This is not it. The cheese pizza doesn't not has the sauce taste and the dough is a missed. The cheese you can't mess that up. Also, the garlic knots are not a New York style or flavor. Hit pass and save the disappointment. The wings are not deep fry either. They are bake and you can taste it in the meat. Who eats bake buffalo wings? Definitely not New York People I can tell you that much. You probably get smack in the face if their order was as bad as minds. I would of done it myself but I'm trying to change my ways and live in peace in georgia. Been there done that. Bottom line your better off going to Marco's Pizza or Johnny's Pizza. These two are not great but far better than I love New York Pizza. I pay $42.00 for this order and it won't happen again. Sorry guys you just don't got it. Sad thing is I drove 15 miles on diesel fuel just to be disappointed and out $42.00. Live and learn. Wish you the best with that trash food.
Pizza was OK my son enjoyed it, should be renamed more akin to Cici's than New York style.
So disappointed this evening. After doing the toy run in rain and just getting home from jasper. Thought we order pizza. I called an girl was having trouble hearing me and I repeat my info many times and even tried to have her to repeat it to me to be hung up on. She told us pizza to be here in 25 minutes. Hour after that still no pizza so called back and she had messed up all info. Spoke with another employee who told me it was on way and gave her correct information. Waited another 20 minutes for it to finally arrive. Cold pizza and slow delivery wasn’t what I paid for. We are so disappointed
Food is terrible. Pizza sauce is really bad.
Stopped by the other day after delivering a load to the Kroger next door. Let me tell you this was the BEST pizza I’ve had in a very long time. So good I had to call and tell them. I will definitely be back next time II’m in the area.
Good food and friendly staff. Sometimes I eat in and a few times I ha e taken out. I made a short video here; I Love NY Pizza in Canton, GA is in Woodmont Village