Possibly the best slice I’ve ever had. Honestly, reminds me of Italian pizza on the streets of Rome. This is not your large corporation American pizza. This pizza is hand crafted with fresh, quality, clean tasting ingredients and is perfectly foldable or equally as delicious with a fork and knife. The right balance of crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings to allow each bite to be graced with the full flavor of the ingredients. I personally had a slice of their current special, Prosciutto and Arugula. The Greek salad was a perfect accompaniment to my slice and was topped with homemade balsamic vinaigrette (which made a great addition to the slice later). The restaurant was clean, well decorated, had a great “vibe,” and although I did not partake, a wonderful selection of wine.
What a fun find in Buford. Italian Pie is really great. We had the lunch specials - lasagne and spaghetti with meat balls. They were $12.99 each and came with a really nice salad, and a drink. The portions were large, the salad was fresh, and the service was great. We spoke to the owner, who recommended a Chianti, that we really enjoyed as well. Go to Italian Pie - you’ll thank me.
We just had take out from here, the Rustic. It was GREAT. We both really enjoyed it and will return for more pizza in the future. They do not just serve pizza so we may try other items. But honestly it was the best pizza we have had around here in a long while. Enjoy!
No need for anything more, the best pizza in Northern Georgia.
Always delicious!! Fresh pizza, calazone and good wine. What's not to love? Awesome owner from Southern Italy!
Amazing Zah! I love a good pizza but this rates high in my books! They use a zesty sauce and the pepperoni is spicy too. Fresh Mozzarella and just a Great Zah!
Finally a really good pizza place nearby. Huge improvement over the previous owners at this location. The staff is friendly, the service is fast and great, the food is great, and the prices are very reasonable.The lunch lasagna is very tasty and large enough to take half home for dinner. The garlic knots are soft and delicious, unlike the hard doughy knots elsewhere. The tiramisu is amazing! The staff are genuinely nice. Keep up the good work!
Finally after 30 years of searching my dreams have come true I found a place worthy of calling it self New York Pizza. Walk in grab a slice fold it and go I'm there just about every day .Family owned and operated the staff there could not be any nicer So people I challenge you to find a better slice in GA go have a slice if your place is better tell me about it I will go and if your right I will gladly buy you a pie.i will be checking on a daily basis so let's see what you got I put my money on the Italian pie
Pizza gets 3 stars. Loved that they had sliced sausage, instead of crumbled and pepperoni was good. Crust was very soggy in places and could have used more cheese. The garlic knots get 5 stars! Sooo much garlic butter and very good texture. You get a good amount of them as well.
Best pizza in Georgia. I am NJ native and this place really is top tier when it comes to pizza.The owners are so personable and service at this location is just as amazing as their other locations. Wishing Italian Pie continued success and longevity. They are a staple in every community they are in.