Simply one of the best pizza’s in the town! We took veggie thin crust pizza which is equal to regular crust pizza in general if we get from some other place and garlic bread. Their 2-3 serving pizza was huge and we(2 people) couldn’t finish it off. The garlic bread came with marinara sauce and pesto sauce which was delicious. Both items were delicious but it seemed bit expensive to me. I’ll recommend this place!
Was actually really presently surprised with Nancy’s! Took advantage of an Uber Eats deal that was BOGO stuffed crust personals and also had a thin crust mushroom pizza. I will say our Uber Eats experience was rather annoying as despite the order marked “ready to pick up!” we still had to wait 20 mins or so. Other than that, staff greeted you immediately upon walking in and were courteous. Inside was kind of depressing, though, quite empty and bar was seemingly out of commission. Takeout joint for us!In terms of the goodies- one of our stuffed crust had busted open and quite literally all of the cheese had poured out which was kind of a bust but the other stayed in tact. Was comparable with real Chicago style pizza I’ve tried in Chicago! Fluffy buttery and sauce was on point. The thin crust wasn’t really thin but I guess in comparison makes sense. I loved how they cut into bite size pieces! Good flavor all around and mushrooms were delicious (but somewhat sparse). I do think it’s over priced for the sizes but the quality was up to par. Not the NY style pizza I know and love but definitely something worth trying and probably the most memorable pizza I’ve had in ATL.
We arrived at this location at 7:30. We ordered a deep dish pie. It has been an hour and we are still sitting here with no food, despite there only being two other tables in the restaurant with patrons. I am beyond frustrated and quite honestly angry. No one has even come over to acknowledge that we are waiting here without food for as long as we are. I will never come back here.
Really great pizza! Got the thin crust instead of the deep dish, which was around the same thickness as a regular pizza. Mozzarella sticks with marinara were also bomb. They even had the marinara heated up, nice touch ?
I’m a frequent customer here at Nancys and have been for years. The pizza is usually very good. However, nights when Sheila is working are nights I will be avoiding this restaurant. They made the mistake of mixing up my delivery order by putting the wrong receipt on the box, and Sheila decided to argue with me about how it was my fault and that the customer is not always right. In a situation where good customer service was required, it was not given. Thankfully there are other Nancy’s in the area that I can support and receive good service from. If you’re looking for a pleasant experience, I would not get your hopes up with this location.
We have ordered take out from here several times and it’s always been delicious. We’ve tried the deep dish, thin crust, and the rustic pizza and all are so yummy! Don’t sleep on the French fries y’all - they’re addicting. Prep time for our orders are usually super quick too. Last visit we were accidentally double charged and they were quick to fix it no questions asked. Great customer service and we will be back again soon!
went here tonight food was great service was impeccable ? you guys did Chicago proud I'll definitely be back‼️
First time having a deep dish pizza and it was fantastic. Make sure you order well ahead of time, about 45 minutes if possible. Friendly people and good food. If you aren't used to this, it will put you in a food coma.
Idk I use to love Nancy’s until my last 3 recently orders. Just completely trashy burnt pizza and old salad. They were nice enough to replace the wrong pizza with the right but burnt pizza. I also used my credit from a previous salad that was old only to replace it with another old salad. Yeah I’m done with this place.
Next to being in Chicago, it couldn't get any better than eating here. Italian Beef sandwiches, Chi deep dish pizza and tavern style pizza, (thin crust) cut into rectangles are all incredible!