Good value. Love that you can schedule pickup time on the app and drive up to pick up at the window.
Not sure what has happened to this store, but customer service has gone from 100%-0% in a matter of a month. The guy at the register was just plain rude, he was more worried about browsing through his phone than to help the customers. There was no one in the store, everyone was standing around just talking. I’m very disappointed. Will think twice next time I decide to order a pizza from Papa John’s
The pizza taste good and the workers are very good .
I don't know what's going on but lately my pizzas have been burnt. My husband isn't picky & when he says it's burnt & can't eat it there's something wrong. This evening I tried again & like I said burnt. Instead of the manger working with me & trying to find out why they pizza is coming out extremely dark just gave me an excuse & proceeded to tell me her didn't want my business anyway. Never had a problem with Baxter Street. Atlanta you need to get it together. Sent it back & asked for a refund. Never will order there again.
Best Papa John's location by far. Incredible staff, clean kitchen and great management. Even while busy they are so nice and make great food. I go out of my way to come here and always tip extrq. So worth it.
I am tired of getting calls every time I place my order saying they can't deliver because they only have one driver. It has happened multiple times now. I don't always have funds on my card and I always have cash but I always get a call saying they can't deliver it because they only have one driver. I'm tired of it.
The manager on duty was the absolute worst. I will never ever visit this Papa Johns EVER AGAIN!!! Made excuses for their garlic butter leaking all over the pizza, all over my seats.
They delivered the wrong ordered, didn’t get refund or the right order. Worse costumer service.
The worst place ever shaq should take his face and name off of it this is the third time in a month i have ordered pizzas only to be told it was delivered but no driver never came they take it upon themelves to not deliver and just cancel your order tonite i was told they have no drivers why offer delivery with no drivers but offered door dash whom i dont trust with a pet of mine with all the bad experiences ive had with them and their drivers ,if youre in the athens ga area you better take my advice dont order from papa johns looking for a decent meal your kids will probably enjoy bc they really dont care but if you want a guaranteed hot pizza that wont take long to get delivered call bulldawg pizza on milledge you will never go wrong i only order papa johns for my bc my two kids order but its a scam a waste of money i wish a -10 was offered thats what i would rate ive learned its good to listen to reviews awful place bring back the old pizza hut from the 80s and close all these awful places down with their unprofessional ppl working there i have probably 10 free pizzas here that i havent went and picked up bc i feel like its a waste of gas fire everyone and close this place down
The quality of pizzas has gone downhill in the last month or so. I gave Papa Johns four or five stars before, but I couldn't even finish my jalapeno pizza because the jalapenos were rubbery. That was two weeks ago.Papa John's needs better ingredients.