Pepe's Cantina Winter Park

433 W New England Ave A, Winter Park - 32789
267 reviews
Mexican
(321) 972-4881

I absolutely Pepe’s Cantina. My coworkers and I come weekly. Their food is always fresh and the homemade guacamole is AMAZING! GM Jose and the manager William are very attentive and efficient. We don’t have to tell them our order, they already know it! If you are looking for good food and great service, this is the place to be!

The food was AMAZING!!. The drinks were good and the service excellent. We shared the Hawaiian fajitas. Best of all the table side guacamole the best

We’ve never had a disappointing meal here. We had an early Sunday evening reservation and were helped by William on their front patio. His recommendations and attention to detail were amazing. He suggested the vegan ceviche with shrimp and the loaded Topo Chico to drink. He was so helpful with our dietary restrictions and made thoughtful swaps like their home made corn tortillas vs flour. The fajitas for two is a massive portion and so delish and we love that we each get our own plate of tortillas and dressings. We love Pepe’s!!! Pictured are the drink and ceviche. We dove into the fajitas too fast!

We had another great experience! Our server was amazing and William is always so accommodating. He makes sure that we are well taken care of and it’s greatly appreciated. This is our third time here and every time has been exceptional! The food is amazing and fresh, the drinks are great and the service is incredible. Our family highly recommends Pepe’s Cantina in Winter Park! We will be back again soon.

Completely enjoyed our dinner here. This was our first time being here and it did not disappoint. We had the burrito which was huge and delicious. We also had the steak chimichanga. The steak was seasoned impeccably. Our server was also a delight. Made funny jokes and she always made sure we were attended to without being overly aggressive. Highly recommend.

This place is INCREDIBLE! I stumbled upon this restaurant while craving Mexican cuisine. The service is second to none. I am not a fan of waiters that bug you every 5 seconds and Naomi was simply amazing. She recommended great options, kept the small talk to just the right amount and was very kind and sweet. The staff had chips and salsa ready within seconds of us arriving as well as water. Our tacos were made to order and the margaritas were amazing! It was my sister’s birthday and she had the best time. I will definitely recommend this place to my friends and will definitely be back soon. 15/10

My wife and I tried Pepe’s Cantina last night for the first time with another couple. We were very impressed. Excellent service, and the fajitas Del Mar are to die for. The portions are extremely generous. My wife and I had the table made guacamole and then split the fajitas Del Mar and it was more than we could eat. If you like octopus, you have to try these fajitas. It’s the best octopus that I’ve had in Central Florida. The guacamole is made tableside, which is great because you can identify what you do and don’t want in it. The chips are light, crisp, not greasy, and are not salted. All very good things. The salsa is mild, which was perfect for my wife, but if you want it beefed up, they can bring you a mixture to add that will strip paint. Be careful with it. The drinks looked good, but we opted for Negra Modelo, which they have on tap. We would heartily recommend this restaurant and are looking forward to returning.

We were a group of 9 old and good friends visiting for the weekend. Had a great table (outside), it was a very, very busy Friday night, so service maybe a tad slow, but servers were wonderful and the food was terrific— burritos, fajitas, tacos—- anything you could want. Asked for guacamole for the table and got a whole show as a young woman made it at the table—— delicious! Wish I lived close by so I could visit frequently. Highly recommend.

This place is located in beautiful Winter Park, it is a great location. The bar was closed due to bartender training, but it is really small. I sat at an outdoor table. The drinks are good. The food is excellent, I enjoyed every bite. My only complaint is $6 for one taco, a single taco, that's insane, it's double the price of any place I have ever gone to and you can see from my reviews, I go to a lot places. It's also $3 for literally a spoonful of guacamole. The hot sauce is good, although I couldn't tell if it was house made or from a bottle, but still good. The service was excellent, my server was on point and very attentive. I will eat here again, the price doesn't keep me away from good food, but does get my complaint.

Today was our 1st time there and I absolutely LOVED the place. Will definitely be back. Food and service was amazing