Goodfella's Pizza

1601 US-1, Vero Beach - 32960
124 reviews
Pizza Chicken Wings
(772) 569-3473

I spent $60 on food that is an edible the subs are burnt the bread is burnt the roast beef on the suppose of steak sub is no better than a cheap piece of lunchmeat my cheese on my pizza is slid off and it is overcooked so very disappointing I will not be ordering from you guys again

The manager went above and Beyond The call Of Duty to grant me a favor While I was in rehab And I really appreciate it.It's good to have somebody in the community that cares about their Customers And I Recommend them to everybody.

Got 3 orders of “Crispy” wings for the game. They were almost crystallized. They crumbled when you bit into them. Nobody could eat more than one or two before giving up. Really disappointed.

Excellent pizza. First time ever visiting that fine establishment. I was impressed. Can't wait to try all the other goodies on the menu.

Definitely the best Steak Stromboli I've had in a long time! Just wish it came with more marinara. Highly recommend it.

We saw a review where the guy said it was “the best spaghetti and sausage he’s had in 15 years” so we tried it out…The service was super pleasant, the place was nice and clean, AND MY PLATE OF SPAGHETTI WAS HUGE!!! Absolutely delicious, and came with yummy garlic knots and a salad. My wife got stuffed shells. Both meals were excellent and it was really quite inexpensive compared to some of the establishments in Vero Beach.Goodfellas will definite be a new favorite for us. (And I can’t wait to try the pizza… it looked amazing!)

Pizza by the slice. Everytime I've gone in the guy behind the counter is super friendly. I haven't tried any other food but haven't been disappointed for a slice at lunch yet.

My husband & I were looking forward to tasting their food, but we were very disappointed. The first time ordered a lasagna & a hot sandwich. The lasagna was average at best & somewhat dry & kind of bland tasting. Looks nothing like the picture on the menu!! The sandwich was mostly bread with hardly any meat. We decided to give the benefit of the doubt in case they were just having a bad night the first time & tried a second time with pizza & some wings. HORRIBLE!! Pizza was dry with barely any sauce & was like eating cardboard & the wings were so hard. The sauce that should have been on the wings was instead pooled on the bottom of the box with none of it on the wings. So much for a second chance try! Never again!!!

Was craving a slice of pizza... look at this thing!? It’s huge! Very tasty ? great customer service, background music through ceiling speaker, and beautiful wooden setting. I’m coming back ?

Their pizza is very good but tonight I decided to order some wings. I ordered the Honey BBQ wings and was sadly disappointed. The wings were over cooked and flavorless, the sauce was too sweet with no bbq taste, it was all honey. The sauce seemed to have melted off the wings because it spilled and seeped through the bag by time it got home. Not good at all.