Sammy Joe's Pizzeria Cafe

8760 SE 165th Mulberry Ln, The Villages - 32162
189 reviews
Pizza Italian Chicken Wings
(352) 633-1949

I bought a $25, 16" Hawaiian pizza, that is now sitting in my trash. Also another medium pizza 14"with half extra cheese and half beef. Looking at both pizza's you really had to try very hard to find toppings and decided which pizza was which because of the lack of tiny pieces of toppings. After spending $43 for two pizza's, I would expect more flavor and toppings. My order was for carry out. Photo attached of Hawaiian pizza. zoom in to see the toppings, or lack there of.

The pizza is delicious and very reasonably priced. If you like a pizza with a lovely thin crust this is the place for you!

Wanted to try this place because I heard it was good but the online hours are incorrect. We shouted up at 5 and the sign on the door says that they close at 2pm - Google says they’re open until 8. ? Will update the review when I can try it

New to.the area, and tried Sammy Joe's. It was wonderful. Service was excellent, same with food. We will be back.

Greasy pizza more than likely from cheap mozz. Def not New York pizza that i ever had. Service was adequate other than i dont need schooling on pizza.Limp dishrag is all i can say??‍♂️ In contention for one of the worst weve had.Dont waste your time. Hit Little Joeys od Francescos

Today was the first time I've orderd a pizza from this place, I have to say it was one of the best pizza's I have had, it was a special large two toppings, pizza was well cooked and the taste was amazing. Crust was thin but they put garlic and basil on top of the crust, great taste. My father has bought pizza from this place before and pizza's were always good but the pizza today was excellent. The ladies who work there were very nice and polite, also very fast. Thank you.

Best Eggplant Parmigiana that I’ve had in a long while. Next thing I will try are the meatballs. If they measure up to my Godmothers, the same recipe I’ve used since I have had my own house then I will be happy. Great little spot and great music!

Wow talk about over priced $52 for 20 wings and a stramboli that my kid could make better . Will never go back there . Where's the meat???

First time trying this place I was very impressed young lady that greet you at the door from the outside was very nice and polite the pizza was fantastic and the antipasto salad was delicious I highly recommend this place and will definitely be back thank you

What a great place! I have been working for Carol’s business for around 4 years. We have been through thick and thin! Couldn’t be more thankful for the amazing things this restaurant has taught me! And can’t forget about the food!! Great pizza, subs (grinders), best Alfredo in the villages, and much more!!! Give us a try sometime! ?