For the Friday night dinner we were looking for a pizza place and we decided to have pizza from Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza. We ordered Cheese pizza and veggie pizza online through their website. The order was ready in 20 minutes and we picked the order from the counter. The pizza were hot and delicious. One of the best cheese pizza we had in Tampa. The best cheese pizza in Tampa. Amazing place to try pizzas in Tampa.
Pizzas were so delicious and juicy too eat with a great taste and good quality and their service was very good.
If your visiting Tampa and you find yourself in the city hungry for a slice you gotta come here. All different kinds of pizza deli style ready to go. Delicious!
This is an “interesting” place and a little confusing for a first timer. Which door to use, where and how to order and pay. Once we got through that finding an adequate place to sit as it’s crowded during lunch hour. We figured the self order kiosk and opted for a fresh cooked pie vs. the endless array of pre-done slices that line the counter. Ordered placed where oh where do we get our drink cups? Another area set aside for fresh orders from the kiosk. Pizza takes a while but we’re ok with that where not on a clock like most of the patrons. Pizza was good, thick crust good sauce and plenty of our chosen toppings. Drinks are self serve and easy fill and refill making the cost negligible if you plan to drink plenty. Will be back to try some of the other menu items but wait until after 1:00 when the working people need to be back at the office.
We're east coast pizza snobs, and Eddie & Sam's gets a thumbs up. You can tell with the first bite. If you get that loud crunch as you bite into the crust, that's an essnetila first step... and they've got that nailed. The sauce was good, the cheese was fresh. Toppings were interesting and slices are huge. The place is bare bones, but the pies are top shelf.
This place is overrated we ordered 6 slices and paid almost close to 27. bucks never got receipt so will find out fro bank tommorow when the pizza came out they were hard as rock literally had to throw it away and when asked one of the server he said they lying to customer about water coming from ny for there pizza they use tap water for there pizzas the place is filthy trash all over the bathroom is even filthy this place should be checked by the health department more frequently
Delicious pizza! We got the gluten free one and it was amazing! I love how they aren’t cheap with the toppings and make sure that each of the slices have good amounts on them. I also love that they have an extra crispy option! Will definitely be back very soon!
The pizza was so good! Had a Sicilian pepperoni and sausage slice and also 2 Supreme slices... they were amazing! Took me back home to Jersey awesome...
First time here! The pizza is amazing! I got a sausage amd pepperoni Sicilian slice and 2 Supreme regular slices and a pepsi... so freaking good! I'm from NJ and it took me home!
I was skeptical on New York Style pizza in Florida, but this placed was very tasty. Parking can be a bit difficult but definitely worth the trouble. I really liked the self-order kiosk, it made things go super quick. They offer a good variety of pizza by the slice - I really enjoyed their white pizza and pepperoni. I did takeout and it traveled very well. The small boxes were flimsy so just make sure to hold from the bottom. They were well staffed for a Sunday early evening and very friendly. They were quick to check on my order when they saw me standing and waiting. Pretty sure I was in & out within 10 minutes.