Midtown Pies

1122 Thomasville Rd #4, Tallahassee - 32303
135 reviews
Pizza Beer Bar
(850) 765-4120

I was not quite sure if this place is Midtown pies or Gaines Street pies when we walked in based on marketing on Google vs printing on container products inside. Oh well, the pizzas were tasty and hit a home run with "Honey, I shrunk the pigs" pizza. Honey drizzled on pizza has always been a winner for me and the candied jalapeños, made our day! Hardly any heat, which made it the favorite for our kiddos out of the three different pies. Last thing, more toppings on the pizzas please to reflect the prices paid for pies.

Nothing like ordering a pizza for delivery, ChowNow telling you "it'll be delivered by 2:51", and at 2:22 there's a knock on my door because the best pizza in town is already here, hot and fresh and clearly only moments out of the oven. If you ask me where I'd like to get pizza from, it's gonna be the Pies chain every time.

Very good pizza with some unique and interesting topping combinations. My partner is gluten free and she RAVED about their gluten free crust, best she's ever had. I recommend asking for your pizza well done, since otherwise its very flimsy and will collapse under the weight of the toppings, but thats all personal preference.

Pizza taste great...roaches not so much :(

As soon as you get in, you start feeling like a family at Village Pizza. I ordered extra large veggie pizza with a large pizza dough stretched out to be XL size and requested them to bake it well done via light sauce. Came out perfectly matching how I imagined my pizza would be. There are not many places like this. Thanks guys.

Coming from Chicago I wanted a delicious sausage pizza!! This is by far the worst pizza and ceaser Salad I ever had. Though was extremely chewy and on 2 sausage per slice. Do not I repeat do not order this pizza if u want a delicious pizza. Even my daughter said what is this and she is 3 loves sausage pizza. Never again what a way to to start my first visit to Tallahassee

Good pizza, GREAT salads & outstanding service!!! the Cobb salad was to die for and the cashier working the front was so friendly.Will be back.

Guy on a Buffalo! Great Pizza and they delivered it to the Bar next door so I didnt miss any of the game.

A little pricey, but the food is always amazing and well worth it

Place was great. People were nice and the food was delicious! Would recommend to anyone who likes Pizza and Sub Sandwiches.