Just met the owners and tried the pizza for the first time at the Civic Center. The owners were super nice and the pizza was delicious. I can only assume getting it at the restaurant is even better.
Our calzones were identical orders, but the consistency wasn't there. Barely any ricotta inside and I counted about 5 mushrooms, which were an extra cost. I'll stay away from this place and get a real calzone for less. The marinara that came with it tastes like crushed tomatoes from a can.
I don’t usually do reviews but seriously? Over $9 for a sub that came with 5 strips of fake chewy chicken.. I added peppers and onions and they were bigger than the meat. Another $10 for a pizza that should be labeled a personal. These two came to over $35 for delivery. This was horrible.
Brooklyn Pizza is the REAL DEAL. Everyone OUTSIDE of NYC/NJ like to claim " NY Pizza" , however 90%+ of the time its a " fake out".Brooklyn Pizza is authentic as can be, and the Owner has his " Pizza Game" right at 100%.What a pleasant surprise nestled here in Tallahassee Florida.Who woulda thunk it-NY Pizza in the deep deep South!
This is the best pizza I have had in a long time. The supreme is terrific, the staff is very helpful and nice.
The best pizza that I’ve ever eaten. Absolute best! Friendly staff and very welcoming.
Yeah this is not good. Way overpriced! Pizza was hard as a rock, meatballs tasted like they were from a frozen bag. The sauce was good but doesn't matter if your meatballs and pizza aren't. Wish I got pizza from somewhere else :(
Usually their garlic knots are soft but it looks like they forgot them in the oven. Was very upset about that.
Wanted a break from the holiday food and went to a "go-to" quick meal - pizza and wings. We wanted to try a different pizza place this time and chose Brooklyn Pizza (for delivery). I ordered the veggie pizza, which included mushrooms, tomatoes, broccoli, artichoke hearts, and eggplant (a bit different from the usual mushrooms/green peppers/black olives/onions veggie pizzas). My husband ordered the steak and cheese sub, which was quite sizeable. We also ordered buffalo wings. Everything was good; will definitely plan to order from this place again. Next time, I will try the Spinach and Feta pizza!
BEST PIZZA IN TALLY! We come once a week for the lunch special. Owner is super nice and really chill environment.