I love an original Greek salad with no lettuce. Theirs is great. Mooussaka is wonderful too. The lemon chicken soup is fabulous. Too many others too mention. Nostalgia is my favorite restaurant in Stuart!
This was our second visit to Nostalgia. Our first visit was when Nostalgia first opened and we weren't impressed with the service or the food quality or presentation. A second chance was given.We sat at the bar by choice. Our bartender was indifferent with no personality. Seemed as if he hated his job. The bar was not that busy so there was no excuse for this poor attitude.We ordered the octopus as an app. Two tentacles placed on a plate with barely any sauce or greens. Unappetizing presentation. It was just okay. We then ordered the Chef Sampler seafood entree. Again, it was okay.The menu is Greek/Italian with some interesting selections. A personable bartender would have made our visit more enjoyable.
Absolutely loved this restaurant! Food was delicious and perfectly seasoned! So many choices, I can’t wait to go back and try other recipes. Eduardo was our server and very attentive! The owner came out also to check on our service. So kind and wonderful. Can’t wait to go back!
One of the absolute best restaurants in Stuart. Great prices, delicious food, welcoming staff, and sizable portions. Whenever I suggest another restaurant, my boyfriend tells me it’s not worth going out to eat if we’re not going to Nostalgia. One of my family’s favorite places (and we’re all NY Italians who miss our NY Italian food!)
Service was superb. Food delicious and perfectly seasoned. Eduardo was our server and very attentive to serving us. The menu had so many choices . I look forward to returning and trying something else. I ordered coffee after my meal. It was even perfect, no cream or sugar necessary. A nasty storm hit while we were there, no rush to send us out. What a wonderful time! Look forward to going back !
Whenever anyone in our group has a birthday . . the party is held here .. fabulous Italian and Greek food . . the lamb shank and the chicken parm are my two favorites
I came here on Valentine’s Day and it was the best place we could’ve gone. The wait was short and the owner even came to us himself and asked us how we were. But most of all the food was incredible!! I got the pasta with Vodka sauce and it was so filling and delicious but the price was reasonable as well. Definitely will be back
Food was AMAZING. Best vodka sauce I've ever had. My only regret is I couldn't finish it!Pasta fagoli soup was tasty. Bread....yum! Look forward to revisiting Nostalgia.
Amazing food. The saganaki, Greek lemon soup, chicken francese, and chicken Romeo were all spectacular. I have not had quality Greek or Italian food since I moved from NY ten years ago. Not disappointing at all. We will be back.
Ordered two Greek salads with chicken and they were amazing. Came with two amazing soups ( pasta fajoool at this place is fantastic) bread and all the fixings. Everything was delicious, and we are coming back in person to enjoy more. Bravo