What a gem! Authentic “up North” pizza! I’m an Italian Jersey girl, from a restaurant/pizzeria owning family, so I know a thing or two about good pizza. Thin, crispy, not too saucy, not too cheesy—all QUALITY ingredients. So flavorful and cooked perfectly. We had a plain cheese to really test how good it was, and then a spinach/Gorgonzola/mushroom pie. We enjoyed them both. The service was great (grazie Anthony!) and the owner Jimmy was so genuine and personable. We live 2 hours from here but we’re already planning our return to try their dinner menu. This is the real deal Napolitana pizza!
I came here after some friend of friends said this place was reviewed by the barstool sports guy. So obviously this place has some major hype. I don’t really follow that guy or anything but they said the pizza was amazing. Anyway, yeah I think this pizza was pretty good overall, but I wasn’t blown away. I drove like 30 min to get this pizza and maybe it was overhyped and I came with expectations being too high? I’m not sure. Either way I was let down a bit. I feel like if I stumbled on this place myself and ate here with no expectations my experience would’ve been a little different, maybe not. Who knows? Still pretty good pizza but nothing too crazy. Decent flavor, good ratios, but there was too much crust for me (although it was crunchy which is good). The other people I was with rated it lower than me, saying they weren’t a huge fan of the cheese. It just didn’t feel like I got that much food for the price either. I easily could’ve eaten a large pepperoni pie myself. I do have a big appetite though. Anyway, yeah I feel like four stars for me is accurate because it was still above average. I might try it again in the future.
Jimmy and his multi talented crew have really captured that Wooster street essences in their apizza!!! My first bite of mootz from Fantini's brought me back to my 1st ever experience in my early teenage years on Wooster Street. There's no pizza like New Haven Pizza except that at Fantini's!!! Jimmy continue your legacy in South Florida and folks reading this review you will not regret stopping in to Fantini's for bite of anything!!!
Hubby has been raving about the New Haven style pizza he had in a road trip thru CT, and when he found out there was one in Stuart, Fl he drove out to pick some up for me.We got the Esther's Eggplant, Jimmy's Favorite, and Spinach/Mushroom/Gorgonzola. Our favorite was the eggplant one - we could not stop eating it. The other 2 were also great but we could only handle a slice of it. Jimmy's favorite was spicyyyyyyy (I loved it, hubby's taste buds couldn't handle it tho haha). The Gorgonzola (aka blue cheese) pie was very rich, but you'll enjoy if you love blue cheese.Hubby said he was expecting the pizza to be a bit thinner. However, as someone who never had New Haven style pizza, I thought they were absolutely delicious - toppings were plentiful, sauce flavored perfectly, and crust super crispy.We also got tiramisu and cannolis - the top of the tiramisu was a bit frozen..? Not sure if it was still thawing from freezer or if it was just an issue with their refrigerator? Regardless it was still delish.
My wife and I try new pizza places in the Treasure Coast and Indian River County. I had Lorenzo's (Ft Pierce) #1 for over 2yrs, but after trying this cheese pizza tonight (3/19/22) this is clearly the best so far. Its our new #1. Great flavor. Great sauce. Great crust.
Aleluya!! Amén!! For this restaurant ?? the best pizza in town! Delicious!! Amazing!! The service always the best! Antony the server he is the best! And the owner super humble and very nice person!! And the place very nice atmosphere ❤️ The calamari is fried to perfection and the marinara is perfect. This is the shrimp scampi pizza!! Yummmm you can feel the butter, garlic, shrimp and the crust perfecto!
First off I am on vacation and therefore unfamiliar with diners expectations for Italian restaurants in Florida. That being said I was extremely disappointed there were three TV's in the dining area! Seriously, three TV's! I expect to find TV's in bars and pool halls not in restaurants. The service was adequate althought inattentive as we had to repeatedly ask for our water glasses to be refilled. Food was ok, nothing to rave about. The veal in my dish was sparse and overcooked. Side salads were large and fresh. The restaurant was busy and appears to be very popular. So, it looks like the owners are meeting diners expectations. I was underwhelmed and will probably not return.
If you looking for a good pizza and something close to new heaven style you definitely need to come and try this place, I had so many pizza's in south Florida and nothing taste like new York style.
I gave this place a second chance, first time I ordered pizza and wanted prosciutto and the girl said they didn't have it and never heard of it, tonight I ordered Vodka pasta and there where only 3 tables. it took 55 min and the waitress gave me a bunch of bull as an excuse. The pasta was nothing to talk about I could've gotten that from Olive Garden which I NEVER go to but that's what I would image it would taste like. The pizza was just OK I guess you have to be from New Heaven, thin and soggy.
This is the only place I will go to get pizza. The atmosphere is perfect and all of the staff is very friendly. Yesterday when we were there, the owner even stopped by to check to make sure everything was good and of course it was!