The service was quick and friendly. I feel like there is a lot of potential here. There was a ton of chicken on my chicken bacon ranch pizza and I believe that sapped the moisture from the pizza. It was pretty dry and much better when dipped in sauce. The size of the pizza and the value was great, I think with another visit this may be a higher ranking. Unfortunately with so many choices in a short vacation that second trip will most likely not happen.
Great atmosphere and service. We have visited St augies several times and never disappointed. We walk in all the time and get pizza by the slice. It's always great. The wings and pasta are always good too. We ordered delivery today and our sandwiches were pretty great too. The bread was very fresh and had a great texture.
The best pizza St. Augustine has to offer! We love the option of walking in a just grabbing a slice or ordering a pie to go! Always hot, fresh and delicious! Love the variety and not to the mention GARLIC ROLLS!! St Auggies Never disappoints!
Went here on our first nite in town, early on a Saturday night. There's no decent pizza where we live, so pizza is a must when on vacation. We split a meatball Parmigiano sandwich & a pizza (brought most of the pizza home). Service was good, although if you're going to eat there, they might offer real cutlery. It's heartwarming to see the pizza dough being tossed the old fashioned way.
The meat balls are a masterpiece. Highly recommended if you like a good meatball. So light and fluffy. Pizza is NYC style pizza mainly and is now my go to pizza spot in St. Augustine.
Closest to NY pizza I have found since arriving a year ago
We stopped for a quick lunch for slices. The pizza was excellent- the crust was crispy and the pizza was hot. The staff was friendly- we were happy we stopped in. Give it a try!
Great authentic Pizza loved it!
pizza is very good I love the authenticity
I only had an on-the-go slice of plain pie, but it was outstanding. Maybe a bit heavy on the sauce, but also heavy on the cheese. Pricey, but its St. Augustine.