If you can mess up Bruschetta so bad this is the place. We were so disappointed in this restaurant. It all tastes like frozen food reheated in the microwave. They are a sad representation to Italian food. The waiter was great but the food… we’ve had better gas station food!
Was wanting some Italian food and my buddy tells me about this place. He says he hasn’t been here in a few years so we both decided to see if it was as good as he remembered. Well, let’s just say it didn’t disappoint. The food was amazing and the service was great. Our waitress checked on us numerous times throughout our meal. I would highly recommend this place if you are in the area.
My husband and I LOVED the pizza from Pizzalley's!! We got the 10' to share, but definitely wish we got the 17' to bring leftovers home.. so well definitely be going back for more!
Amazing!! Ooh the burrata and pizza della nonna.. yum! Remember they only accept cash or you'll be stuck using their ATM.
This used to be one of my favorite spots in St Augustine. I would hit the slice shop for a slice, a breadstick and a beer. The slice shop is gone and has been converted to rank among the dozens of redundant desert spots on St George. Had to go in the back and order and wait for a whole pie, which was still good but everything else good about stopping here is gone.
My wife came for dinner. We both had eggplant parmesan and caesar salad. The food and service were excellent. Highly recommended!
Pizzalley's was not worth waiting in line for. My pizza was so so. They only take cash, which was disappointing to me, since I know that most people don't carry alot in this day and age.
Mother's day they got us in with a minimal wait time. The meal and service were both excellent! I would highly recommend this restaurant
What lovely place for lunch with the family. Lovely atmosphere and staff. We sat outside and service was quick. We got the “Garbage Dump” pizza which fed everyone well. Will come again.
I cant visit st Augustine without stopping by the Pizza Alley an unassuming entrance on St George st will fool you into thinking its a tiny hole in the wall but follow the corridor to the left and through the door into an italian trattoria a full bar to your right indoor dining to your left and a large covered porch for outdoor dining. I highly recommend the "garbage can pizza" (I skip the black olives, personal preference) which has EVERYTHING on it,a hand tossed crust and a tomato sauce remniscent of Boston's North End.The drinks are a generous pour the servers friendly, polite and personable and their are numerous choices for beer and wine.No trip to St Augustine is complete without a meal at the Pizza Alley,trust me you will be pleased.