The cutest little place with lots of outdoor seating, but it is a little pricey
My family came hear after hearing about this place. We were underwhelmed. Don’t get me wrong it’s a cute place with nice workers but it could be better. It’s an ice cream sandwich nothing really special about it. It could have tasted better. The milkshake drinks are not even given lids. I wouldn’t come hear again, nor really recommend it. I have faith that maybe one day this place will be better.
Amazing flavors. Fresh ice cream with generous portion on crispy cookies. An absolute must in St Augustine !!
We had a good ice cream sandwich here. It was expensive. If it was layered with pie filling, it sure didn't look like it...but it was good on a hot day. Had to eat it outside because someone was smoking pot in the back and the store reeeked of it.
This is an awesome place for ice cream sandwiches!! They have such a great selection. We had the Coffee Toffee Carmel and Salted Carmel Apple Pie. They had two shortbread cookies with a little pie filling on top of ice cream. They also offered cookies dipped in chocolate with toppings too. Our group made sure we got there and will go again next time.
I visited this store for the first time and had the key lime pie and it was amazing!! 10 stars!! I decided that I was going back every day to try different flavors. When I returned the following day, I had the strawberry shortcake and there was hardly any pie filling and there was less ice cream. The ice cream tasted good, but it was nothing like the initial experience and the point of getting it is the mix of the ice cream and pie filling. . Now I'm left disappointed and unsure if I want to go back.
This is a very unique ice cream place. The staff was super friendly and they were great about explaining how the "pies" are made.
Peace Pie has very good ice cream sandwiches and a lot of different options to choose from. If you have a taste for some good ice cream sandwich stop by Peace pie in St.Augustine Fl
Great ice cream! Went there twice this past week. The girls working there are super cool,too!
Ice cream sandwiches with an ice cream and pie filling. Such interesting flavors! Chatted with the owner and learned that they have two other locations - Cape May, NJ and Charleston, SC. Will look for them the next time I am in those towns!