My sisters and I arrived late in the evening and this was our only choice for food, so we decided to give them a try. Well they certainly didn’t disappoint. The service was excellent, the ingredients were fresh, and the pie and garlic knots were delicious!!!!! Oh and I forgot to mention the crust was light and the pizza wasn’t greasy at all. Give them a try, you won’t be disappointed! Thank you Five Star Pizza!!!!!
Ordered a pizza from here at 11:30 pm, and it was delivered quickly, and the pizza was great. Delivery driver was polite.
After an agonizing 10 hour drive— To begin our Saint Augustine vacation. We checked into the Fairfield Inn & Suites. My husband, daughter and I were starved—Pizza!! #1 go to — We called Dominos and they were super busy and recommended Five Star Pizza. ( shocked at the humbling and customer service) My husband spoke with an employee from Five Star and was immediately impressed with his exemplary customer service skills and positive attitude. We ordered and they even brought the food to our room!! Impeccable service!! Delicious food!! Highly recommend. They even gave us paper plates to use. !! A+++
I just ordered from their . The pizza is good. I ordered wings and their was not enough sauce to my liking. Called them up getting their sending dome more with sauce on thr side thank you!
Always a good experience no matter the time you go in. Everyone behind the counter is always professional. May not be the cheapest in town but the quality is good(for pizza) and love that they are open late
Fast delivery, very good price and the Hawaii-Pizza was great.But the garlic Rolls are over the top - try it!!! Not the usaul garlic flavour - real garlic in oil - very tasty - we love it
What happened to this place it use to be a great place for cheap pizza that actually taste good. Now it’s just blah and the staff is the same way. Hit or miss place
I am (or WAS), a first-time customer with Five Star Pizza. I spent $48. and some change on two pizzas. A large pizza w/pepperoni, ham, beef, onions, pineapple, and banana peppers. Also, a medium pizza w/extra sauce, extra cheese, and mushrooms. I wanted and asked for thick crust/deep dish for both pizza's. When I picked them up I looked at them and they didn't appear to be thick crust. (But, then I thought, maybe this is what they call their thick crust.) I went straight home and sat down to eat. It was then that I realized I had the closest thing one could get to being thin crust. We tried to eat it but it tasted like a grocery store freezer section pizza. Absolute pathetic! Hard outer crust with no flavor!My rating: ONE STAR for Five Star Pizza. And it simply gets one star for "effort." I can get better pizzas at Little Ceasars for half the price and drive less than a mile. I, obviously, do not recommend Five Star Pizza.
FIVE BIG STARS as advertised.I ordered the Deluxe with extra Cheese and a side of Garlic Butter to aid the crust. Wow..Fresh Indgreients, the cheese is superior to other chains. The woman that took my order was charming and polite. FAST delivery was not even ready yet. Thats a good thing when your already hungry. Now I ate too much but that's not thier fault. Choose 5 star, I highly recommended, thank you ?
Five Star is our family's pizza restaurant of choice! They have the best sauce around! My personal fav, cheesystix with pepperoni, have always been stellar. However, the last 3 times they have arrived doughy. Despite my "well done" request. I've called twice and they politely replaced them but I'm tired of being THAT customer who has to call and complain every time. I'll either have to stop ordering my fav or just plan on baking them myself. Not cool.