????? ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ BEST Pizza in St Augustine! The aroma will get to you once you walk in. One taste of their Pizza is so tender but with a light crisp crust that is hard to capture at most places. All Natural & Fresh ingredients that melt in your mouth from the 1st bite to the crust. Wonderful Owners! Excellent Pizza & Variety of Pasta Dishes! I couldn't wait for my 1st bite...
I have to say I will never order from here again. My order was to go and I ordered a pizza, calzone, garlic knots & chicken fingers (for the kiddos). My pizza and calzone had absolutely no pizza sauce on it and my garlic knots were hard. Extremely disappointed!!!
Love love love their food. Will definitely be back! Our server was super sweet and knew everything about the menu. Great recommendations. We got the Honey Datil Sauce wings. AMAZING!We also got the supreme pizza and the piggy pizza. Which were also amazing. Thank you so much!
Ok so when you first pull up its like there’s nothing around, dead strip of businesses after hours. (Dr offices, realtors) there were 3 cars in the parking lot. I was skeptical. We were recommended to eat there so we decided to keep heading in.Inside very clean, 3people working. 4 booths and a couple table setups, one huge oven and the back. At this time they serve pizza and pasta.We ordered the supreme. Pep/onion/green peppers/ mushroom. They hand toss the dough too.We were greeted by the manager, Tiago, who is from NY and two other gentlemen . They are super friendly and even remembered our friends who were in the other day that recommended them, which was cool. (Customer recognition goes a long way).We paid and sat down and while we were waiting Tiago brought us some garlic knots to try. The sauce they use is great. Perfect combination of sweet , tomato and saucy! Garlic knots were perfectly cooked.Pizza came out promptly. They brought it over to us, and got us plates/silverware (even though it was out for us to grab ourselves)First glance, pizza is HUGE! Crust was perfectly cooked- not hard as a rock but not soggy. Right thickness. Veggies were fresh! Sauce was awesome. You could fold the pizza with ease. Not too greasy but just enough to give that NY style flavor .I’d recommend this place over other local pizza places such as Antonio’s, 1000% over pizza chains and even comparable to Tony D’s Brooklyn pizza. (I’ll be back to try their margarita pizza for full comparison to them)While we were eating, Tiago came out and chatted with us. We swapped food experiences etc. he then brought out a Datil pepper wing sauce he makes for their wings, along with a house made ranch sauce to sample. First taste of the wing sauce was “oh this is sweet tasting” then BAM! Hits you with the kick. Paired with the ranch, that also has a sweetness, perfection. A little too spicy for me but those who like spice would probably love it. I’d probably actually try it again on wings . We ended our food experience with some Gelato. Yummy!!!!Overall I’ll give it a 10/10. We’re going to order pizza for our wedding for the kids from them as well and will definitely be back for more food.They are working on adding subs, so keep them in mind!!
Top 5 in NE Florida for sure. Pizza is insane, toppings are fresh and delicious. Sadly I ate my take home leftovers as soon as I got home.
The pizza is amazing! When we arrived the owners were welcoming and answered any questions we had.As we waited they provided us with complimentary garlic rolls that tasted great.The pizza was very delicious. Perfectly cooked with ample toppings. Cannot recommend this place enough.Venture out of the city center for 3 miles and find the best kept secret of St. Augustine!
Was great service! Tasty food! Friendly conversation and fresh pasta what more do you want!
My husband absolutely loves this place. Really unique pizzas with amazing flavors, hand made pasta and very fresh ingredients. His favorite is The Piggy BBQ pizza dipped in Honey Datil Pepper sauce.What he brought me home to try was super yummy. Good prices and the owner is really cool and interacts with the guests. Definitely our new favorite spot.
My family and I have been struggling to find good pizza since we moved here from Chicago 2-1/2 years ago. We came across 900 degrees Pizza and Pasta and decided to give it a try. Immediately upon walking into the restaurant, I was greeted by the friendly owner and an incredible pizza aroma. I could see a pizza that just came out of the oven and it was cooked to perfection. As a family of 6, we were all eager to try the pizza and it did not disappoint. The pizza had a great wood fired crust with excellent crisp. There was ample cheese and the sauce was fantastic! So glad we gave this a try and we anticipate our next pizza night because it will most certainly include 900 Degree Pizza and Pasta!
Great pizza and great service. We got the all aboard this time. I’ve had almost all their pizzas on the menu and all have been delicious.