SPEARFISH GRILLE

1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota - 34242
411 reviews
Seafood
(941) 349-1971

Fantastic food, legendary service, great value for money. We are going to come back. Compare to the customer service we normally get in Britain, it is day an night. Worth the visit.

Great food again. We were here a year ago and remembered it well enough from its location to come back. Great fresh seafood, had a Mexican corn appetizer that was new and our teenagers loved. Great music and with food that’s very good makes this place a favorite of ours. The only drawback is cocktails in a can plus full beer and wine menu is a little bit of a bummer. Had fish tacos which have been the best all week, the lobster Mac n cheese which was the star of the dinner and then fresh group that was good but nothing memorable.

We had a poor experience last evening with a competitor down the road. This afternoon we hit the jackpot. The grouper was great, the shrimp delicious and the gumbo superb!

Everything was amazing! I ordered the coconut shrimp and dip for an appetizer. It was very fresh and delicious!. After that, I tried the street Corn on the Cobb. Once again, it was amazing! Thereafter, I ordered chicken tacos and they were very good. Lastly, I had the salted caramel cheesecake! This is now one of my favorite restaurants and I will be returning!! Everyone was very friendly and the service was excellent as well. The waiter was very helpful as it was our first time eating dinner here.

Went to an early dinner around 5:00 on a Monday. We were able to get seated inside to take advantage of the A/C. Very small indoor dining but nice outdoor space with room for live entertainment. Waiter was very attentive and efficient. We had grouper cheeks for an appetizer and they were delicious! I ordered the grouper tacos. They were good but I felt like the amount of grouper was skimpy compared to the abundance of black bean/corn mixture that was piled on top. Husband had yellowfin snapper fish and chips and loved it. Daughter had seared tuna Sammy and ate every bite. Prices were what we expected for fresh seafood. We will definitely be back to this place!

The restaurant was great when the previous owners sold the place. The food and service was top notch. You never leave hungry! But now the place has gone with items which are not as good to say the least. Still has the music which is top notch.

The food was excellent. Spearfish are hogfish caught by spear. The fish was excellent, though they only have “whole fish” sometimes. The vegetable medley was superb, and the noon service was excellent. Parking is terrible——ask inside before you commit.

This place, by far, is the BEST place to eat at on Siesta!! AMAZING FOOD, SERVICE and DRINKS!!! If i could give a 20 star rate i definitely would!!! Our waitress Jasmine was wonderful and super polite. Every staff member there was super helpful and you could tell they all were all about team work, helping one another and they all had great customer service skills!! We have ate at most restaurants on Siesta and they don’t compare to Spearfish. Best seafood in town now doubt! Lobster Roll.. BEST EVER!!! Conch Fritters…impeccable!! So much flavor!! Tiki Corn…. WOW!!! You have to try it!! Blackened Grouper… so flaky, falls apart and is mouth watering!! Lobster Mac and cheese…. Out of this world!!!

We’ve been going to Spearfish for several years now. I found it a while back while looking for something with fresh seafood and outdoor dining. This place has both. Atmosphere is amazing, fish is always fresh and delicious, ice cold local beer, and the service is top notch. Also take out is available and is always on point.

Great food! Peel and eat shrimp was great and lobster Mac and cheese was wonderful. Really enjoyed the Key Lime wheat beer. Key lime pie for dessert to top off a great meal.