Jake's Ice Cream on Siesta Key

6575 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota - 34242
222 reviews
Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Coffee & Tea
(941) 554-4632

The cinnamon ice cream is mind blowing! Best ice cream I’ve had in a while

Excellent service from Mrs Sandra Billy, Sandra dealt with everything for my bitcoin Investment and ensured all my withdrawal were quick and efficient. Would highly recommend Sandra Billy to everyone who is having difficulty trading or have been scammed before like myself. contact her now through this. Email: [email protected] WhatsApp: +15128931587

Outstanding ice cream. I spoke with the owners who were lovely. They make all their own ice cream on site. Cannot more highly recommend a fantastic ice cream parlour.

The ice cream is great!! The service is better! Jake came out front the kitchen and helped the staff. He helped me decide on my flavor. The chocolate ice cream is like nothing I’ve ever had before. I definitely recommend. This place is a must visit. Great vibes!!

Excellent Ice Cream; Excellent Service! We showed up right after they closed, all ice creams were covered, floors were swept...and they gladly welcomed us in anyway, they uncovered all ice creams so we got the full service experience. They offered us a taste of anything we wanted.. which all were absolutely delicious!! Thank u for the fabulous ice cream and excellent service! We will definitely be back!!

We stopped here around 5pm on a Wednesday and had ice cream before going to dinner. Good choice!!! Nice selection of flavored ice cream. My wife tried a taste of the rum raisin and her eyes opened wide. Those raisins had been soaked in rum for a good long time. I had a milkshake with a couple of different flavors, all delicious.

We stopped here twice during our stay at Siesta Key. The salted caramel pecan and Madagascar vanilla were our favorite. Strawberry was also good. Staff was friendly. Line moved quickly. Serving size was adequate. Perfect way to end your day after a hot day on the beach. Would recommend a stop (or two)!

We stopped after our fish dinner down the street. This place is great. It does ONE thing--perfectly. No sandwiches, salads, flatbreads, waffles, coffee lattes, chocolate dipped marshmallows, etc. Just GREAT ice cream. We had three different flavors. Every one was great. The cups come with small bits of waffle cones. Not a lot of seating but that should not discourage anyone from stopping in. We are staying in the area for a 3-night getaway. We will probably stop here every night for dessert. If I am going to burn calories for ice cream--this is the place to use them :-)

This is the Best Ice Cream I've had in a long time. Not to mention it's perfect after a hot day at Siesta Key Beach!

OMG what a hidden jem. I think the plaza throws you off. How is something so great hidden in there! Best ice cream ever. Went threee days in a row because the kids and I luved it sooo much. Super unique and tasty flavors at a reasonable price! loved the chocolate sprinkle waffle cone. Our favorite flavors were: cookie dough, cinammon biscotti which tasted like a snicker doodle cookie, cookie dump, and coconut which my daughter LUVED. Ya'll are AWESOME! and super friendly girls at register with a great smile.