I cannot say enough about Caribbean Pie Co! Their pies are AMAZING. Shari went out of her way to help make my mom's birthday extra special. You NEED to try their mango key lime pie!
The Key Lime Pie is perfection in taste & ease of cutting…loved the tanginess of the filling & the solid crisp crust!
After much research and tastings in the Sarasota area, my wife and I have made the executive decision that this is the best key lime pie in Sarasota (Floribbean Flo’s was the runner up)! The filling is what makes this pie. It had just the right amount of tartness and was not overwhelming with sweetness. The only thing that would make this pie better is a thicker crust. Their crust is preformed and not made from scratch; therefore, is thin and soft. The closest competition, Floribbean Flo’s, had a nice graham cracker crust that had a crunch. Well done Caribbean Pie Company! We will most certainly be seeing us each other on a yearly basis!
I have been buying pies off and on from the Caribbean pie company. Years ago and many different locations they used to make the best apple and fresh strawberry pies anywhere. Today they are concentrating on Keylime and cream pies. A couple of weeks ago I bought a Keylime with swirl chocolate which was very good. All my guests loved it. Yesterday I brought to a dinner party the banana cream with salted caramel. Sorry to say this but this pie absolutely missed the mark. The crust was so tough you couldn’t cut it with a fork and it was definitely lacking in banana flavour. So disappointing. Will go back for the key lime pies.
Amazing pies! Original was our favorite! We tried chocolate and mango as well, both were fantastic! Highly recommend if you are a key lime pie lover
The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful. We bought a tropical fruit key lime pie and it was delicious! They even gave us an extra ice pack because it was going to be sitting in our car for a while. We got home about 8 hours after purchasing the pie and it was still cold
The BEST Key Lime Pie I've ever had! Loved it! And their Key Lime Pie Sticks covered in CHOCOLATE are just amazing!
The Best KEY LIME PIE I've ever had -- DELICIOUS! You won't want to miss out on THE Caribbean Pie Company! Simply Amazing -- Lots of Pies to choose from. I will be back for a Pie every time I'm in Florida.
After discovering this sweet pie shop while on vacation in 2021, we made sure to stop the first day of our vacation in 2022. We enjoyed Key Lime pie all week long!
I must say, their Key Lime Pie is Phenomenal...! Truly the Best I have ever had anywhere...! Can't wait to try the other pies they have.I highly recommend this place....!