New York New York Pizza - Riverview

11367 Big Bend Rd, Riverview - 33579
127 reviews
Pizza Burgers Sandwich Shop
(813) 644-7100

Please tell me you've heard of a pizza bag? Everything was so cold I'm reluctant to order again. I can almost taste the potential of a great pizza. I ran a pizza joint up north and we always delivered HOT pizza's and wings by using a pizza bag. Customers wanted to buy the bags from us because they worked so well! I will try delivery once more, then adjust my review if deserved.

I have never left a Google review, but first time for everything right? I ordered my pizza online and it was supposed to be ready at 8:26, I didn’t get my pizza tonight until 8:58. Then I went to the register twice and was told it would be ready in six minutes to different times. I then get home to taste the pizza, absolutely disgusting. I wanted to give this place to try because it was one of the cheaper options in my area, but I will always pay more for better, I guess this is what I get for trying to go the cheaper route. Guys please read the reviews, this is not the place you want to order from.Go to East Coast Pizza on Big Bend!

Very good pizza. They are very good and you can build it as you want it.Will definitely go again. Look as if it is a pick up or delivery place only. No place to sit down and eat. Well worth the price.

Stopped by for a slice of cheese pizza today, and for $2.69 I expected something more authentic. I was pretty disappointed with the pizza being heavy and way too much cheese for my taste. But always pale and almost undercooked. Just average, overpriced Pizza.

Really excited because the name New York indicated the pizza makers would have skills. Unfortunately the ingredients they are buying are wayyy below industry standards and certainly not the quality tomato sauce and mozzarella you’d get on a NY pie. The ricotta was also flavorless. I’ve never had a more bland experience and waste of calories. Second star because it was a step above a Pizza Hut by not by much. Get some better ingredients, please!!

Legit pizzeria style pizza and wings. Just started ordering from here recently after getting bored with the typical chains in Riverview. Wish I'd had ordered here sooner. If you haven't eaten here at least give it a shot. Delivery was on time and food was hot and delicious. Fresh ingredients on the pizza and the boneless hot garlic wings are delicious.

We had been a customer of NYNY for a VERY long time. I was never a fan, but my wife liked it, so ok. I always thought their pizza was junk and very inconsistent in their baking . We would get burnt crust and bread more often than not. Definitely not new york styled pizza, in my opinion. The other day we ordered some garlic knots and as many times before, half of the order was burnt black. My wife called to tell them and ask to see if they could deliver a new order of bread. The girl that picked up the phone apparently handed the phone to the owner, who started disrespecting my wife. So i took the phone and after a few words i told him we would never order from them again. every time they burn our food, they ask us to send pictures. Like , did you not see the food before you went it out for delivery? JUNK PIZZA, TERRIBLE SERVICE! We found this place called diesel pizza on balm and 301, this place is amazing! This is real pizza!! We live in summer field but very much worth the drive!

This is my first and last time to order a pizza from this place, take me 50 minutes to get my order and I understand is a holiday and they must be busy (was the only choice at the time) I pick up my order and I have a surprise when I realize my pizza was missing the sausage, so I call them to complain they ask me to send some pictures to make it right and promised me a credit for my next purchase, after they received the text with the pictures they come with a conclusion. The sausage is there even is not, the funny part is when they said that sausage might be melted with the cheese. At this point I don't expect anything from them I prefer to take my business somewhere else and avoid any kind of confrontation. My best advice is to check your order before you leave to make sure you're getting what you are paying for.Merry Christmas.

Pizza is good, but the fries.... ordered seasoned. They don't even have salt on em

They have some really good pizza, my favorite is the Florentine. Staff is always super nice and friendly.