Wildwood Pizza

117 W Marion Ave STE 112, Punta Gorda - 33950
102 reviews
Pizza Food Delivery Service
(941) 205-8818

My grandkids ended up stranded in PG. Hungry, when I called store, Amber took my info and I was able to buy and pay for their lunch at Wildwood Pizza. They went way beyond my expectations and were great. Pizza was delish too ty

I went with a friend here because of the online reviews and it sounded and looked delicious! I was sadly disappointed. Tho the good reviews were correct about the service and the people working there, they certainly were very pleasant and accommodating , I could not get past the amount of fruit flies literally swarming on around around the pre made slices of pizza on display. Still I stayed and asked if they could make mine “fresh” and I guess they did, as we sat outside and I didn’t watch..Now for the taste …ugh…I really WANTED to like it, but it was nothing like what it appeared online. For 16.50 with tax for two slices, it tasted like toasted bread, not a pizza dough thick slice I’ve always had before. The bread plank was bland and texture was off. I tried fresh prince that was supposed to be a Philly and the meat was garbage although the other ingredients and taste not too bad. Also had that spicy shrimp one that I can’t remember the name of and I couldn’t taste the shrimp inside all the batter and not even sure it was there. But again, the other ingredients were tasty. I couldn’t get past the crust really…even if I chose other toppings.My friend got the New York type plain slice and thought how boring, but honestly hers looked better than mine and one slice was huge for only 4.50. Again nothing special other than the size, but I’m sure hers had bugs all over it before she ate it. They should not keep an open case for that to happen which it will in Florida, but after seeing how many flies were on their food I ended up throwing away my little bit of leftovers , I just couldn’t get past what I saw. So many better options to get good pizza, even in Florida so unfortunately I’d pass on this place…and their flies.

I truly love the pizza but today I was a tiny bit disappointed. I don’t mind waiting as long as the pizza is hot and has quality. I ordered the Barbie Q and I waited like everyone else. I thought they made it there but when I got to my car and picked a slice the chicken was super cold and there were like one or two onions in each slice. Usually the crust is crispy but not today, so I thought that they didn’t make it out of scratch. I will definitely keep ordering because I never had any problems before and the customer service is hands down the best. But please make sure that the pizza is made from scratch, hot and enough ingredients. Just a humble suggestion.

This was a UNIQUE pizza experience in the best way. I had the just pear it pizza. arugula, pears, pecans and HONEY with fresh ricotta. OUTSTANDING. all of their offerings are quirky without being pretentious. very affordable as well

Just had their NY style Pizza with Vegan cheese & vegan meatballs. It’s seriously the best pizza in our area! The slices are enormous…..and the simple fact that they have multiple vegan options beyond just cheese is awesome! Thank you Wildwood Pizza!

This pizza is absolutely remarkably! The buffalo chicken pizza was possibly the best I have ever had in my life ever.in addition the manager on duty was extremely kind in helping me negotiate thru door dash so I got a fantastic fresh hot order would give 6 stars if I could.I appreciate them using fresh local ingredients too.this place is a gem!

Amazing! We got the 420 special with Holy Cheesus, Supee Meat Boy, Maui Wowie and Hogwarts. EXTREMELY FILLING. Far more reasonable than your normal pizza joint that offers less in quality and quantity. We highly recommend!

Was happy to enjoy delicious pizza and garlic knots with 2 friends on a beautiful sunny day, 3-18-22. We split the special of 4 pizza slices plus ordered garlic knots! The we chose four different kinds of pizza and we agreed all were very tasty. Amber was amazing and very helpful answering our questions!

Visiting from out of town and thought we'd give this place a try. Awesome pizza! They have a really cool menu with some unusual ingredients for the pizza. They have vegan meat and vegan cheese options, along with all the usual fare. Took about 40 minutes for delivery. It was well worth the wait. We will definitely order from here again. The app that you use to order the pizza is great and easy to use.

Good food made with precision and love and care but the hosting waiting for bringing the cooking is extremely slow