Captain Phantasy's Amici's Pizzeria

2686 Tamiami Trail Unit 6, Port Charlotte - 33952
27 reviews
Pizza
(941) 391-5010

We are always happy with our orders!! Very friendly staff! We love the family feel!!

Don't order from them they just ripped me off for $36 bucks and said have a good day.

The food is always top notch and delicious. We’ve never been disappointed yet!

Okay pizza. Arrived hot and correctly as ordered. Expected fresh spinach, not chopped, cooked spinach. Not pleasing. But lots of toppings! No scrimping here!!!

Great place with great food. Definitely check it out!

We have stopped at Amicis Pizza at least three time in the past 90 days. Each visit, pizza, stromboli and subs were very good freshly made. Appears to be owned and operated by a family father, wife and daughter, Very helpful. My only complaint is that they are closed on Sunday but when you are a family, you deserve and need a day off...

We have been going to Amici's Pizzeria for years. From the first time we went there through today they have always been consistent and friendly. They make the only Pizza we have eaten in Florida that can compare to a real New York / New Jersey Pizza!!!! We have had most of their menu items over the years and they are all delicious. They are definitely the best Pizzeria in town!!!!!

My husband is in 7th heaven since he found Amici's....great NY style pizza, calzones that are over the top!! They do mostly take-out and delivery, but there is comfortable, covered courtyard seating right next to the building. Amici's has a very nice menu at reasonable prices, friendly staff and an inviting decor. Glad you moved here from Long Island!!!

Moved to the area last year and We have been going to each restaurant in the area just once to find out the best. Port Charlotte has so many great Pizzerias but I have found the best In Amicis. The meatballs I had on the side were as good as I’ve ever had also. Back to the pizza. It’s perfect in every way. Delicious sauce. Quality cheese ( and lots of it)and the crust is crispy and slightly dense and chewy. I even ate the crust around the slice which I never do since it is so good.

If you are looking for an AMAZING PIZZA, then look no further! Amicis has the best pizza and the friendliest staff!