Lost Pizza Co.

550 E 9 Mile Rd, Pensacola - 32514
231 reviews
Pizza American Chicken Wings
(850) 495-5900

I don't venture to this side of town too often but have always wanted to try the pizza here. I was not disappointed by any means. The menus were right there as you walk in, so we were able to grab one and have our order ready by the time we got to the counter. I enjoy being able to choose where you want to eat, so we got a nice window booth. The food came out timely and in order since we had an appetizer first. The Pit Boss signature pizza was a good go to for the first visit and I'm looking forward to trying the others!

I think this place lost their way on to pizza school. Don't bother wasting your money - get a $7.99 gas station pizza rather than their $22 three topping thin pizza and fried ravioli (they ran out of thick crust pizza dough - what?). The fried ravioli tastes like a frozen pizza roll my kids make in the microwave. Seriously disappointed. Only gave it a two because the staff was excellent. You are better off with Pizza Hut and save $50 to feed a family. We received many requests as to where to grab pizza for the family and this will not be on the list. Not sure how it can get any higher than a 2. It's that bad from a value and taste perspective.

Stopped in for a quick bite with my Son and his family after a golf outing. Was pleasantly surprised with great pizza and awesome service. It seems like they have more to offer but what we experienced was just right. Will have to come back and try different menu options.

This was most definitely the best pizza I have ever had. So much flavor !! 100% recommend!

This is a review for Lost Pizza in Destin/Miramar. Love the atmosphere. The house salad was amazing. The ranch dressing was excellent. The pizza was very tasty. The decor was inventive and very pleasing to the eyes. This was my first time there, but not my last one.

Yummy pizza and food. Wings are award winning though? It was pretty good wings to me but nothing crazy. The angel hair gets soggy very fast but that’s most of their pasta options. The Greek salad was delicious though. Overall a great pizza place!

We love this restaurant! Their food is always fresh and hot. Quality ingredients and quick service. We mostly order salads and pizza. Their salads are excellent! Fresh greens, great dressing and decent sizes. Pizza has great crust, their sauce is made by them and has good flavor! The meats/vegetables and cheese are flavorful and good quantities!

The dessert pizza!

Once they take your money they forget about you. My order was wrong, but no one was available to report it to. I am also extremely disappointed with the toppings. You would typically expect that a pizza with a lot of toppings would be delivered with a lot of toppings. I ordered a pizza with nine or ten toppings. What I got had nine or ten toppings, but the portions of toppings were greatly reduced. For example, at least two of the slices I ate had no cheese at all. I only ate half of the pizza. Other slices had almost no toppings. I tried to count pepperoni slices. On a large pizza, I counted eight pieces of pepperoni and ten pieces of ham. I couldn’t find bacon at all. Mushroom, peppers, onions were there, but it didn’t matter because there was so little of it. I ordered no olives. Of course, it was “loaded” with olives. Once I picked all of them off(since no one was available to report to), I estimated there was only about two tablespoons. My impression is that this store advertises a lot of toppings on a pizza, but in reality they reduce the amounts of each topping to the point where it is more comparable to a single topping pizza (at a ten topping price). When I went to get a to go box for this terrible pizza, I was overlooked by at least three people behind the counter before some finally asked if I needed anything. This person handed me a box, and walked away. Didn’t ask how I liked it. Didn’t ask if I needed anything else. Didn’t thank me. They just walked away. I had planned to test my theory of ratios of toppings. I wondered if a single topping pizza would have more of that one topping and more cheese. My impression is that I’ll probably skip Lost Pizza and get a better pizza at Domino’s, or PapaJohn’s, or *gasp* even Pizza Hut.

Great pizza and atmosphere. Thick pan style and a crispy thin crust. They also have a really nice.gluten free cauliflower crust pie.