Mathers is one of my favorite Speakeasy bars. Such a great experience every time we go. Joe the bartender is incredible and can make you anything based off your flavors of choice. Tim the manager has a great personality and had a constant presence as well. Can’t wait to go back!
What an incredible experience! We were greeted by the manager, Dan, who was so informative about the history of the building, gave us clues for entering, helped make drinks, and even showered our bride-to-be with rose petals for the perfect photo! Kira took especially good care of us, was kind, and even rushed to make sure our second order of drinks made it in with minutes to spare before the end of happy hour. This was one of the highlights of our trip!
Such a cool spot! Nice going to a place that has an attire requirement just to grab a drink! The drinks were good, I will say it was strange drinking out of a “bath tub” so to speak, but it was worth the experience. Such a great vibe, cozy at first, but later in the evening it started to get really loud as more and more people showed up. Pretty good drink menu, a little limited on food from what I remember, but then again they’re a cocktail lounge so that can be expected. 10/10 would go again, if only just to walk through a bookcase!
Really cool place and great bar tenders. I most enjoyed the fact that this crowd seems more laid back and mature than most other speak-easy's I've visited. They have a great selection of liquor and super live entertainment. If you've never bee, it surely is something I think most people would enjoy.
Probably my favorite bar in Orlando. The vibe is very old school. Speakeasy style with a hidden door to enter. The cocktail menu was great. Froze on tap. Lots of wine. 50% off during happy hour. Our bartender Alana was great. When asked for a bartender choice she made a passion fruit rum drink with sliced jalapeños.
We had a great time there. It had an upscale prohibition vibe, but the dress code was varied. I had the bath tub, substituted for vodka. It was great! I did get to keep the ducky as souvenir.
Last night I had an amazing time at this establishment! Paul the Poet was an excellent host and wrote my friend and I the most touching poems in no time at all! Tanner Johnson, the violinist, is insanely talented as well and his covers of popular music were the coolest fusion! I cannot wait to come back and have more delicious glasses of wine while listening to the most incredible music! I will absolutely be visiting Paul for more poems again as well, made the perfect gift for my new husband! Thank you everyone that makes this place so magical, I found my favorite place to unwind. Ten stars!!
Excellent experience. Each of our party got different drinks so that we were all able to try multiple ones. Our waitress, Harper, was excellent at recommending drinks and was very attentive. There wasn’t a drink that we didn’t enjoy! We ordered the cheese board; it was more than enough for a party of three to enjoy. The atmosphere was beautiful and bookish. I would recommend this place to anyone and I will definitely make a point to comeback each time I’m in Orlando.
From day 1 we fell in love with this place, upscale, comfortably and the cocktails! I've told the staff... you are not bartenders, you're not mixologist, YOU ARE ALCHEMISTS!!! Steven has got to be the best and most attentive server of all time. Thanks you for an amazing evening once again!
Spectacular atmosphere and great drinks! I'd recommend first timers go during the beginning of happy hour to get a good feel for the place and drinks.This spot has such a deliberate aesthetic and man, the devil is in the details of this place. It's both an intimate hangout spot at the right time, and a great hustle and bustle area when it gets busy. After just one visit, I know Mathers is the type of place that I will end relationships over if my partner says they don't like Mathers.