First time eating at Goodfella’s pizzeria and it was wonderful! The calzone was delicious and the chicken wings were large and delicious. Can’t wait to go back and try the pizza! The service was super too!
Menus
This pizza place definitely earned a special place in my heart! If you want to have special feelings when you bite a pizza slice, this is the place! The chef Joey killed the pizza! Good job buddy! Our servers Justin, Josh, and Hannah were amazing! All friendly staff and will be coming back again! Oh and don’t let me start on the Canolis and garlic knots! They definitely touched my soul!! The service was like a foreign prince being taken care by this servants!
Great family dinner tonight! Food was delicious and the service was on point!
I have been to Goodfella's pizza dozens of times when I used to live in the Orlando area almost 30 years ago, while attending the University of Central Florida and pursuing my Master's Degree. Having grown up in New York City and Long Island New York, I have been to some of the best pizzerias in town. A friend of mine told me about Goodfella's and that it truly was real authentic New York Style pizza. I was very skeptical at first, but after going there and trying their pizza, I was convinced. Goodfella's pizza is as close to New York Style pizza as you will find in Orlando. I don't know how they do it, but their pizza is absolutely and positively the best New York Style pizza that I have ever had while living in the Orlando area. The thin-style crust is perfect. The sauce is perfect and the Italian sausage that they put on their pizza is equally delicious and tasty. Their pepperoni pizza is as good as any of their other pizzas, too. In fact, it seems as though all of their Italian food is made with real, authentic Italian ingredients. Their garlic bread is phenomenal and easy to get "hooked" on, too. The customer service and front counter people are also very nice, friendly and courteous at all times. The dining area is comfortable and very family friendly. So, if you are ever in the Orlando/East Orlando area near the University of Central Florida, do yourself and your family a huge favor and check out Goodfella's Pizza. I promise you that you will be very happy and glad that you did. Enjoy!
This place deserves 6 stars. Though I only got takeout, the food and service is second to none. There is no better taste than authentic New York Italian Pizza! All the ingredients were fresh and the box art was impeccable! If you want some authentic Italian pizza, you will not be disappointed by Goodfellas!
Our waiter was attentive at best but stand offish and seemed a bit impatient with us. The prices were good but not great with limited menu.The young hostess was very strange offish and obvious that she'd rather been somewhere else.The food tasted maybe a 4 outta 10.It was cool, pizza is supposed to be warm at the least but it wasn't and the cheese was falling all over.Like, the cheese was under a hot lamp and the sauce was cool. Odd.
Every time we come to this place, we always seem to have Zachary as our waiter. He goes above and beyond to make sure our experience is top notch. Last nights experience was just that. Both my husband and I were starving from a long holiday trip back home and we stopped into goodfellas. He greeted us like we were his family and offering the specials and recommendations. He never let our cups of drinks go empty and even surprised us with a complementary dessert at the end to take home. Thank you Zachary for constantly giving my little family such amazing hospitality. Cannot wait to go back!
I would have to say this place is horrendous! Our pizza was completely raw and our meatballs were so dry and burnt to a crisp. Not to mention I though Italian restaurants were priced on their homemade red sauce but yet there was grease and some tomatoes pieces with the cardboard balls. It was a pickup order on Friday night. Completely disgusted!
The bruschetta and penne al vodka with shrimp were so good. The stuff pizza slices is good and affordable!
Awesome, the service given by Anabel was great. The food was delicious. Adult size Chicken wings, Adult size portion, I'm not one to be taking food home,that is why we go out to eat, but this time I had no choice, thank you.