HOLEY MOLEY BAGEL BAR NYC

179 College Dr, Orange Park - 32065
95 reviews
Bagels Sandwich Shop Salad
(904) 592-7341

Wow! Delicious! The bagels have a great consistency. Entries tasted amazing. The sitting area is comfortable. The service is quick and friendly. This will definitely be one of our regular places!

First trying this bagel shop and it was amazing. The bagels are miles better than the store brought ones. The Debo sandwich with pepper jack on a Jalapeño bagel was awesome. Even a basic sausage egg and cheese on a French toast bagel was delicious savory sweet combo. The home fries were well seasoned however for the price I expected more flavor and better portion size.

Great service and food a must try.

Delicious food, and super cozy atmosphere.The bagels are perfect, soft on the inside toasty (if you get it toasted) on the outside. They have a large variety of flavors, we got 'everything asiago' and 'french toast'. I got a sandwich on the asiago, a pork roll and cheese, and it was very good. I didn't know what a pork roll was, but I was told it's like "if ham and bologna had a baby" and that's exactly what it tastes like!The home fries and cut up super small, I'm thinking they use red potatoes or maybe those small yellow ones. Either way, the taste was perfect, and you can eat a big spoonful all at once. Also, if you ask them to make them extra crispy, they actually will!

Lots of hype from people I know about this place. I was very disappointed. My bagel was barely warm and no sign of toasting. It was cut into 4 pieces for what ever reason and only the top had a THIN like melted butter layer of cream cheese. Was given a small container of cream cheese in my Togo bag but no knife to be able to put any on. Asked for a knife and they don't have any and gave me a plastic fork ?. Warm soft bagel with cream cheese was gross. Ate one bite and tossed the rest. Very disappointing

ABSOLUTELY love this place!!!! Great people! Awesome atmosphere, family friendly❤️

Best bagel shop around. They are soft, airy, with just the right amount of chewiness! It use to be my Sat mornin tradition to go groc shoppin', then stop by on my way home to grab a bagel. Today, I got the Holey Moley, which consist of all 3 meats (bacon, sausage & ham), egg & cheese. Served on a garlic bagel. ?The staff is always so friendly. They also have amazing art that is done by a local artist that is available for purchase!

We finally got to try this hidden gem. So happy to have a new establishment near us the atmosphere is great. Food was hot and fresh will be a return customer ❤

I highly highly recommend Holey Moley Bagel Bar!!!! Awesome customer service. Clean and welcoming. You should definitely try the unicorn beagle ?? 10/10 for sure.

I love this place! It’s my spouse and I’s favorite place to get breakfast. The food is always great and the coffee is always fresh and hot. The service is fantastic and everyone is always very sweet and delightful to chat with. I 100% recommended this place especially the lox bagel and pork roll with egg and cheese.