Joey's New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant

5205 US-19, New Port Richey - 34652
271 reviews
Pizza Italian
(727) 845-3000

Okay giving the benefit of the doubt have been here several times. This past weekend we went (reluctantly) had a pizza, calamari and stuffed mushrooms. The calamari was typical and not bad. The Pizza we asked to be crisped up and it was not. We ordered a large and left 5 pieces. It was doughy and just bad. The shrooms had a sauce that was off. the shrooms were okay but the sauce on them just had something that was off. The waitress was great but unfortunately we will not be back.

First time visiting this restaurant for dinner with the family. We had a pizza, calzone, spaghetti and meatballs, trio, and shrimp scampi. Every one of the meals was amazing and a huge portion for the price. The only thing we didn’t love was an order of calamari, which was chewy. Our waitress was friendly and very attentive. Just happened to stop here while on vacation and would highly recommend.

Ordered slices of pizza - took forever. Sersly, how long does it take to slap slices of pizza on a couple plates? Get the slices and none of the cheese slices look the same. Mine is not edible at all. I can’t even hold it up to put in my mouth without it going limp and falling to my plate. I will not be eating here again. I’m Italian, I know my pizza. This is not good pizza.

Let me tell you this! I visited the site in N/P Richie. As a Jerzzzz boy, we would either order a slice or appetizer to see the quality. I had two slices, nice in thin, bottom cooked properly, nice fold to slice...only thing that needs a bit of adjustment, is the tomato sauce. A bit acidy. Meaning maybe Joey, could not get the imported tomatoes? Overall for FL. Pizza, Good!!My friend had the veal. Super flavor, tender, nice salad and rolls. Myself garden salad fresh and tender grilled chicken. Our waitress I believe Kim, was special. Joey, be back Wednesday! Thanks,

They'll get your order wrong. And no decent correction. This place was great for a long time, but no longer. No attention to detail, and have no problems screwing up your order. Go elsewhere. Also, they do not care when you call and complain. A great pizza place at one time, going quickly downhill. Avoid.

I read multiple reviews before ordering so I will try to address my experience from previous reviews. I called in my order for the first time and the girl on the phone was nice and, just like any place, let me know my total before my pizza came. I ordered a large supreme pizza and wings. The pizza came loaded with delicious toppings and was PERFECTLY cooked. The wings were plump and the sauce was on point. They told me it would be here within an hour (I ordered on a Saturday night about 9pm) and it was here on or before that time. The delivery driver was cool and I tipped him well because I feel I am a little to the edge of their delivery area (Also, if you tip well in a restaurant, tip your driver well. They actually PAY to get your food to you). Overall, I am fully satisfied with this order. I hate to see negative reviews but I understand stuff happens. as a first time customer I will call back. Some pretty damn good stuff.

This is a local pizzeria that has a nice family type of environment. They have a nice selection of wine, a variety of choices and really good lunch specials. The slices were a bit small than we are typically used to but the food was great

Hunger hit and we weren't familiar with anything in the area. We took a gamble and found this gem! We had the garlic rolls and a Greek salad. Really generous portions, great service, and not expensive. The menu is interesting and has something for everyone. The rolls are a must. The Greek salad is beautiful and lush. The best feta! We'll be back and sending others!

When we are in the mood for Italian food we always go to Joey's.We go to this location even though the other location is closer because the service is generally better.Last night took a while to get our food but they where fairly busy and we were not in a hurry.Nice to see that their menu prices are still reasonable as other places are raising prices.Portions are still good too.

We have gone here several times and it just keeps Going downhill more and more. Apparently they only put garlic butter and Parmesan on in house Stromboli’s if you pick up they don’t put it on. That is the best part and it makes absolutely no sense. Even the girlOn the phone when we called to complain said that’s the best part also! I specifically asked for it because the last time we ordered it wasn’t on there but we thought it was just forgotten. And brought it home and again it wasn’t on it! Also half of it has no cheese. Very disappointing and bad attitudes when you call them. I went in there last week now that i think about it with my friend and sat down to eat and the waitress clearly did not want to be there. Very unpleasant. Consistency is key and clearly they are not!