Cerrato's Italian Market and Deli

908 W New Haven Ave, Melbourne - 32901
194 reviews
Deli Italian
(321) 984-3668

We are new to the area and I stopped to pick up lunch for my family. We ordered 2 roast beef, 1 meatball and 2 sausage with pepper and onion subs for take out. I waited 15 mins for them to make more bread to accomodate my large order which I did not mind. The bread is excellent and well worth the wait. The roast beef and meatball subs were also very good. The sausage subs left a lot to be desired. They were swimming in sauce with a fair amount of sliced sausage. We had to dig thru all the sauce to find 4 or 5 small thin pieces ( not even slices) of peppers with no onions in a 12" sub. When I called to let them know that they forgot them I asked if I could go back and get some for our sandwhiches. I was told that he did put them in there. I offered to bring the sandwhiches back and show him there were none (again giving him the benefit of doubt for forgetting) I was told very rudely that I can bring them if I want but that's what he puts in there and we weren't going to get any. He claimed he can only put so much in a sandwhich. I understand that food costs are high and some cuts need to be made but they should either take the peppers and onions off the menu and change the name of the sub to sauce and sausage or if cuts really need to be made... leave off some of the sauce the bread was swimming in. Unfortunately, I did not ask for any names when I was talking to them. The lady that waited on us was very friendly and gave great customer service. The older man that was cooking is very rude and for that ( and the lack of peppers and onions) we will not be back. I sure hope he isn't the owner!!

My colleague and I went here for a quick lunch. The anti-pasta salad was delicious, and the sub was fresh and huge. We both only ate half, but I only waited a short time to finish the second half because it was just that good. Get it all the way, you’ll thank me later. While we were there, someone came in and said they came all the way from Connecticut to eat a sub from there because they made the best something that I unfortunately couldn’t make out as we were walking out. I’ll be back 100%.

Best Italian sub in the city! This deli is a hidden gem, if you’re looking for authentic food this is the place to be in Melbourne ?

Great authentic Italian deli sandwiches. It was well worth the wait. Soppressata provolone sandwich, pasta and antipasti salads and topped off with a slice of tiramisu. I highly recommend this place.

By far the best customer service and there sandwiches are 2nd to none they are 1 of 1 in this county next sub I have ever had. I know some of you are Publix fan but you can’t compare a Bentley to a Kia sorry y’all but this by far the best place.

We got the turkey and Italian subs. They were amazing.

Amazing small business and the sandwiches are the best Italian sub and fresh baked sub rolls the deluxe has prosciutto and thick sliced mozzerella! Soooo good!

Oh my goodness, all of the local praise is well deserved! The kindest assistance with outstanding sandwiches. A must try when in the area.

Great spot, definitely worth doing a pick up if you’re even close to this place. Lovely owners, authentic jars and foods to buy. Most importantly the food is delicious and they don’t skimp on the size. Bring an appetite and go support this long standing business!!

Wow. Where has this place been all my life. Perfect sandwiches. Great bread. Tasty antipasto salad. It will be come a regular for me. Cashier was delightful.