Maybe not the WORST pizza I’ve ever had, but it’s a close second. Crust was tasteless, dry, and brittle. I prefer light sauce, this place apparently leans toward ‘invisible’ sauce, so unable to comment on flavor. Cheese was a blend I believe, and also ‘dry’ for lack of a better explanation as to reason for ‘no stretch.’ NY Style Pizza seems to be a common title when a business needs a ‘draw’ as this is the polar opposite of NY Pizza. Sorry, won’t be back.
So disapointed. First pizza was basically saucless. Second time i ordered i explained the issue. Her responce , charge me for xtra sauce which i have no problem with . took two screen shots . dry pizza again . she didnt want to see the screen shots. Just excuses about sauce running off the pizza in their oven. I hope i can post these pictures . dry pizza no sauce around the edges to run over. Ive owned a country market in ny for years. Selling 800 pizzas a week and as many hot subs. The saying , the customer is always right , holds no bearing to these folks. Must be an ego thing is all i can figure. See the pictures. Extra sauce , dry dry dry !
A bit expensive, but a GREAT pizza overloaded with toppings. Totally worth it.
Great little mom and pop pizza joint with very friendly service.
Honestly so good I even know the people who work there go there a lot definitely a good place to go 5/5
Great pizza!!!But they always close wayyyyy earlier then 8pm sucks for a lot of families I went today at 718pm to order and they were already closed lights off and all
Great food and Awesome service. Family owned and operated….you won’t find better Italian in North Lakeland.
This is NOT an El cheapo pizza chain! It's a local mom & pop with outstanding food and reasonable prices. I can't begin to describe the quality... it's definitely a treat! All pizza should be this good! ?
Excellent food and service. I am a Celiac; allergic to any amount of wheat in a recipe. Although it is not on the menu, they took the time to prepare a breadless version of their sausage sandwich. It was fantastic. My wife was also very enthusiastic about the pizza she ate. Sarrentos Pizzeria is now on our short list of great places to eat.
I highly recommend this NY style pizza! The slices were perfect!