They had the best cookies!!! The ice cream was delicious and homemade. I got the Cuban coffee and the one with their fresh cookies mixed in. It was so good we went back the next night.
Bought cookies and Key Lime pie. Both were delicious and would recommend stopping in at least to get some air conditioning on a hot evening. Once you smell all of the baked goods you will have to get a few things!
We stopped in for some of those monster half lb.cookies and some fudge. Very clean and friendly service. ? We also ordered 2 of a chocolate base macaroon. Best I ever had and very large. Definitely will come back here in Key West FL.
They have several locations around town, you a not miss the smells coming out of their stores.The cookies are ginormous!We had to try the key lime pie of course: it was a bit to sweet compared to others we had.Overall, we'd go back for the experience: their ice creams looked so good!
Awesome cookie and customer service. They were super friendly and explained all the steps they take to make one of the best cookies I've ever had. It's a must stop if you love baked goods!
The cookie is absolutely delicious!! The ice cream is amazing! And the picture is just one scoop! And thank you for the kind man who helped me carry the ice cream ?
Walking by the window I saw the enormous cookies and was pulled in to see exactly what they had. I found a peanut butter cookie iced with peanut butter and chocolate fudge that weight about 3 pounds. We bought it on the spot and share it for lunch, it was terrific but I would recommend splitting it with four people instead of two because it was so rich! very nice staff. Would highly recommend!
Excellent Key Lime pie. Great looking cookies.
Absolutely excellent!!!! Extra large amazing baked goods and ice cream!! Best place in town by a mile! We ordered a triple scoop of 3 different.ice cream flavors for $9 and were given 4 scoops overflowing in a 16 ounce cup. So so delicious! We had just been to Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shop a block away and had ordered 2 scoops of ice cream for $9 and were given 4 ounces in a tiny cup. We were speechless and it was very average flavor. . Mattheessens ice cream is hand made and tastes amazing!
Great key lime pie and ice cream. Massive cookies.