The have key lime pie on a stick with chocolate, or individual slices. If you have a lot of people buying the whole pie will save you some money. Whole oies are frozen or refrigerated. I bought the whole pie and biked it back to the hotel to put in our fridge. It was perfect the next day. Love all the items you can buy in the shop as well, or miscellaneous snacks. Nice seating inside or out.
We just stopped in and got a single piece of pie and we liked it. It’s a good key lime. However, we tried key lime pies at several places and I am not sure that we found one that was noticeably better than the others.
One of the best key lime pies in the keys! We ordered the chocolate dipped key lime pie and it was so delicious. We tried 3 different spots for key lime pie and this was one of my favorites.
We came in when it was a bit slower and had a chance to talk to the owner who is so sweet. We ended up getting key lime pie and cheesecake. Both were very good. We did most of our vacation gift shopping here. We were glad to support the store owner who took over shortly before the hurricane and then the pandemic. After hearing her story, we wanted to support her. I would recommend this store as my number one place to get gifts and pie in Key West.
The key lime pie was really yummy. The key lime coconut pie was lackluster.Souvenirs are pretty dated.I honestly think you can find better key lime pie just a short walk away from here.Don’t go out of your way to come here…but it’s also not awful.Employee working was also not very kind.
We loved the key lime salt water taffy and the cookies. When we got home we ordered more of both. It is a tasty key lime
At the time of our visit they did not offer gluten free pie crust so the option was custard in a cup. The pie filling is prepackaged and frozen rather than fresh which was a bit of a bummer. It thaws pretty quick but you have to be a little patient. The flavor is knock your socks off good! So glad we gave it a try even though it was crustless.
You can order the pie by the slice to have there or whole to go. The pie is delicious, the traditional style without the huge topping. The shop is appealing and carries many other items, both food and souvenir.
Friendly staffs. Clean and cool; nice dinning windows view.
Cute store great souvenir's and Delicious Key Lime Pie!!! Went to store to look for Key Lime items and there was nothing. Great gifts to buy.