When I first step foot into the Holey Moley Bagel Shop, I was welcomed with warm, energetic smiles and the unbelievable fresh smells of NYC bagels that come rushing at me at the entrance. I was overwhelmed by the options in bagels and I needed to try them all, so I told the manger I had to get one of everything to go. Completely understanding and compassionate in my move, he grabs a brown paper bag and guides me through the process. There's raisin, cheese, happy rainbow, garlic and onion flavored bagels all in one area. I even tried their breakfast sandwich, 'The Heart Attack,' and man that was just a journey of its own. So, if you're looking for a breakfast experience, then come on down to The only, Holey Moley Bagel Shop!!
Best NY bagels in FL forsure‼️Love the Chopped Cheese too,only place to get one just like NY Deff going back all the time making it my go to spot, them Cinnamon Toast Crunch waffles are crazyyyy
Lox Everything Bagel with Garlic and Herb Cream Cheese & Tomato Slice...Very Tasty Bagel Imported from the Bronx and prepared well!The employees were very kind and interested in my thoughts...and it was surely TASTY! This is going to be my new favorite Bagel-Spot because I am Jersey Girl who misses the perfection of food from the North-East.
Breakfast sandwiches are outstanding. You can have on a fresh toasted bagel or roll.Would have been a 5 star but due to a national shortage of cream cheese, they did not have all the flavors for our take home bagel order. It is possible they are using a off the shelf brand of veggie cream cheese instead of making there own due to shortage. The veggie cream cheese was just not right with odd flavor.Soda drinks offered are plastic bottle. Great for on the go, not great for dining in.
I've been twice so far and I think they've won me over for favorite bagels. They are perfectly soft and crispy. The sandwiches are the perfect size for breakfast and taste great. Service is friendly.
Saw a coupon in the local Coupon Magazine for a buy on get one free NYC Bagel sandwich so we figured why not. First parking is good but this strip mall needs to be cleaned more often as trash cans are over flowing and stuff is flying around so ZERO ⭐. Now I cannot hold this against Holey Moley. Entered and warmly greeted. Sandwich selections are written on a Blackboard so reading them is a bit of a challenge. Wanted Lox, Cream cheese, onion but they were sold out of Lox so we settled on Lox and Cream Cheese mix on Sesame Seed and another on Everything Bagel both very good 5 ⭐. Bagels were so good we took home 6 for $7.89 which is a good deal 5 ⭐ Just know that they are busy with hours only from 8:00am till 1:00pm on weekdays and 7:00am till 12:00 noon on Sunday and they do sell out of items which to me is good as everything is fresh. We plan to return ty try the many different sections so suggest you also do.
I've been twice so far and I think they've won me over for favorite bagels. They are perfectly soft and crispy. The sandwiches are the perfect size for breakfast and taste great. Service is friendly.
I've never been to NY. With all the talk about their bagels,I believe this is the real deal. This place is small, but they had a revolving door of customers. We were only there for a little bit, (we dined in) ordered our food and sat down the guy brought us our bagel sandwiches and we dove in. Everything was very delicious and the bagels were so fresh and soft on the inside, made for a great breakfast. They also sell coffee, donuts, subs aswell. We will be back!
Real deal NY bagel shop...finally!! Stopped in and I had the sausage/egg/cheese on an everything, hubby had ham/egg/cheese on a plain. Bagels pillow soft, with the right amount of top NY crunch and plenty of filling! Very nice, clean, family owned restaurant. Nothing fancy but killer food. Can not wait to go back and try more. Definitely get their early as they do sell out quick!
Great bagels brought in from NYC and breakfast sandwiches. Great service. They know me by name and always make it how I like it. Amazing Apple fritter bites when they have them!