Renna's Pizza

592 Marsh Landing Pkwy, Jacksonville Beach - 32250
155 reviews
Pizza
(904) 273-3113

Great pizza, flatbreads and garlic knots

Decided to order take out here based on the website history of “two brothers from Italy”. We ordered Lasagna, Spaghetti and Meatballs, and Chicken Parmesan. All were average at best. I guess I would recommend sticking with pizza.

Truly the best pizza and Greek salad! I always eat here before and after appointments. great food

Very pleased. I ordered the Lasagna and it was quite good. I think the portion size is good for two people. Large green salad. The garlic bread could use more garlic, a bit bland. No complaints. Very polite,friendly and helpful staff.

Best New York style pizza in the area. The crust folds properly. Only one I have had like that nearby. And the New York cheese cake is amazing. It is lighter than most… with a raspberry topping that was out of this world.

When I entered I wasn't even greated then I had to find a menu. Everyone after me, yes everyone had a warm welcome. No one ever checked on me, or delivered my drink. I'm the only one here now but the counter help was all over the other table. I never even got a "How is it?" You can have decent food and great service will make it worth while. Mediocre food and no service, disappointed. I thought I was entering a family establishment. My pizza was drenched with liquid and no one even cared to ask. Doesn't pizza get sauce? Don't guest get served? Overall disappointment!

I'm so confused about all the good ratings. As a family of 5 we did not like anything. We got the pepperoni pizza and we thought little Caesars tasted better. The meatball sub was disappointing, the spaghetti was the most blandness I've ever eaten. My 12 year old even suggested refrigerating overnight to see if it absorbs flavor. It barely had sauce though. They almost forgot my salad and that was actually the best thing we received. Oh the garlic bread was good, but you can't really mess that up. Ordered around 740 pm... maybe I should try day time? Idk but that was a lot of money wasted. There's another shop 10 minutes away that is way better so we may not go back to try again.

I'm so confused about all the good ratings. As a family of 5 we did not like anything. We got the pepperoni pizza and we thought little Caesars tasted better. The meatball sub was disappointing, the spaghetti was the most blandness I've ever eaten. My 12 year old even suggested refrigerating overnight to see if it absorbs flavor. It barely had sauce though. They almost forgot my salad and that was actually the best thing we received. Oh the garlic bread was good, but you can't really mess that up. Ordered around 740 pm... maybe I should try day time? Idk but that was a lot of money wasted. There's another shop 10 minutes away that is way better so we may not go back to try again.

The staff is wonderful and the pizza is delicious! I highly recommend it.

Amazing pizza and service! Highly recommend them, we will be back!